Salem MA for Halloween's Best Restaurants [Updated 2025]

With a total of 15 restaurants personally reviewed and tested by me, you can trust that this list is the cream of the crop when it comes to a memorable dining experience in Salem during the Halloween season. From hauntingly delicious dishes to spine-chilling decor, these eateries have it all.

Whether you're looking for a spooky ambiance, delectable Halloween-themed cocktails, or simply a place to enjoy a frightfully good meal, this article has got you covered. Get ready to tantalize your taste buds and embark on a culinary adventure like no other in the bewitching city of Salem, Massachusetts.

Ledger Restaurant

Highlights
Excellent service
Flavorful cocktails
Innovative menu
Culinary excellence
Unforgettable desserts

Let's start with the excellent service I received at Ledger Restaurant. From the moment I walked in, the staff was welcoming, attentive, and accommodating. They truly made me feel like a distinguished guest.

Now, let's move on to the flavorful cocktails at Ledger. The bartender impressed me with their mixology skills, as each drink was meticulously crafted and bursting with unique flavors. The seasonal twist added that extra touch of Halloween spirit to my dining experience.

Ledger Restaurant boasts an innovative menu that truly showcases their culinary excellence. The dishes presented not only delighted the senses but also challenged traditional flavor combinations in the most delightful way. I particularly recommend their smoked butternut squash soup, which perfectly captures the essence of autumn.

But the highlight of my visit had to be the unforgettable desserts at Ledger! Every sweet creation was like a work of art. From the rich chocolate pumpkin tiramisu to the spiced apple tart, each bite transported me to a world of Halloween indulgence. The presentation alone was enough to satisfy my sweet tooth.

In conclusion, Ledger Restaurant in Salem MA is a must-visit during Halloween season. Their excellent service, flavorful cocktails, innovative menu, and unforgettable desserts make it a top choice for anyone seeking a truly remarkable dining experience. Don't miss out on this culinary gem when planning your Halloween festivities in Salem MA.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Boston.

Dire Wolf Tavern

Highlights
Truffle fries appetizer
Siren's Song sushi roll
BOGO sushi deal on Tuesdays
Delicious cider
Fantastic Halloween decor

Picture this: a place immersed in the enchanting atmosphere of Halloween, where every corner feels like a spooky delight. That's exactly what you'll find at Dire Wolf Tavern in Salem MA.

First, let's talk about the food. The Truffle fries appetizer is an absolute must-try. The irresistible combination of crispy fries and truffle oil will bewitch your taste buds. For sushi enthusiasts, the Siren's Song roll is a delight for both the eyes and the palate. Bursting with fresh flavors and cleverly presented, it's a true masterpiece.

Visiting on a Tuesday? You're in for a treat! Dire Wolf Tavern offers a BOGO sushi deal, allowing you to indulge in even more of their delectable sushi creations.

Now, what would Halloween be without a deliciously spooky beverage? The tavern offers a range of options, but don't miss out on their delicious cider. It's the perfect drink to sip while immersing yourself in the spine-tingling ambiance.

Speaking of ambiance, Dire Wolf Tavern takes Halloween decor to a whole new level. Every nook and cranny is adorned with eerie touches, from skeletons lurking in corners to flickering candles creating a hauntingly beautiful atmosphere.

In conclusion, Dire Wolf Tavern is a Halloween lover's dream come true. With its tantalizing dishes, unbeatable sushi deal, delightful cider, and mesmerizing decor, it truly stands out as one of the best restaurants in Salem MA for Halloween. So grab your broomstick and head on over for a bewitching dining experience!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Boston.

The Derby Restaurant & Bar

Highlights
Great customer service
Excellent food and drink selection
Lively atmosphere
Delicious and unique flavors
Knowledgeable and friendly staff

The moment I stepped into The Derby Restaurant & Bar, I was greeted by a spooktacular atmosphere. The dimly lit dining area was adorned with cobwebs, pumpkins, and eerie decorations, setting the perfect Halloween mood. The staff, who were dressed in their wickedly creative costumes, welcomed me with open arms and their great customer service truly made me feel like a part of their haunted family.

Now, let's talk about the food and drink selection. The menu at The Derby was a true treat with a wide variety of dishes to satisfy any ghoulish craving. From savory to sweet, their excellent selection left me spellbound. I delighted in their deliciously tender Braised Lamb Shank, which was expertly paired with a sinfully smooth pumpkin-infused cocktail that tasted like autumn in a glass.

What impressed me the most was the restaurant's commitment to delivering unique and delicious flavors. The chefs at The Derby truly know how to cast a spell on their dishes, combining unexpected ingredients to create mouthwatering surprises. Each bite was a tantalizing journey into the realm of taste, making my Halloween dining experience truly unforgettable.

The knowledgeable and friendly staff added an air of enchantment to my evening. They took the time to explain the unique ingredients and preparation techniques, ensuring that I fully appreciated the hauntingly good flavors before me. Their passion for food and commitment to delivering a spine-chilling experience truly put The Derby a cut above the rest.

In summary, The Derby Restaurant & Bar is a must-visit for anyone seeking a fang-tastic Halloween dining experience in Salem MA. With their excellent food and drink selection, lively atmosphere, and great customer service, this haunt is sure to leave you with a taste of the extraordinary.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Boston.

Settler

Highlights
Incredible visit
Delicious cocktails
Exceptional dishes
Friendly service
Highly recommended

My visit to Settler during Halloween was nothing short of incredible. From the moment I stepped inside, I could feel the festive and spooky atmosphere that makes Salem so unique during this time of year.

The cocktails at Settler were absolutely delicious, and the perfect way to start off the night. I tried their special Halloween cocktail, which was a clever twist on a classic drink with a spooky twist. It was expertly crafted and had just the right amount of haunting flavors.

When it came to the food, Settler truly went above and beyond. The establishment is known for its exceptional dishes, and they certainly did not disappoint. Their Halloween-themed menu offered a wide variety of options that were both delicious and creatively presented. From the macabre appetizers to the frightfully good entrees, every bite was a delightful surprise.

What truly set Settler apart, however, was their friendly and attentive service. The staff members were knowledgeable about the menu, offering recommendations and accommodating special dietary requests with a smile. Their warmth and enthusiasm added an extra layer of enjoyment to the overall experience.

Overall, I highly recommend visiting Settler in Salem MA for Halloween. With its incredible atmosphere, delicious cocktails, exceptional dishes, and friendly service, it truly embodies the spirit of Halloween in Salem. Don't miss out on this spooktacular dining experience!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Worcester.

Olde Main Street Pub

Highlights
Delicious food
Fun and friendly staff
Amazing street corn
Flavorful fish tacos
Super delicious steak sandwich

Let me start by saying, wow! This place truly encompasses the spirit of Halloween with a playful and festive atmosphere. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a fun and friendly staff who were not only dressed in elaborate costumes but were also passionate about making my visit enjoyable.

Now, let's talk about the food. Oh boy, did Olde Main Street Pub deliver on taste! Their menu had such an enticing array of options to choose from, making it difficult to decide what to order. But fear not, for I managed to try some of their delicious dishes that left me craving for more.

First up, their street corn. It was a delightful blend of sweet and savory flavors that had me reaching for another bite. And speaking of flavors, their fish tacos were out of this world. The fish was perfectly seasoned, and the accompanying toppings added a burst of freshness.

But the star of the show was undoubtedly the steak sandwich. The combination of tender meat, melted cheese, and the super delicious bread made my taste buds dance with joy. It was a culinary masterpiece that I devoured in no time.

Overall, Olde Main Street Pub is a prime example of the best restaurants in Salem MA for Halloween. With its delicious food, fun and friendly staff, and a welcoming ambiance, it's the perfect place to delight your senses while immersing yourself in the Halloween spirit. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Plymouth MI.

Sea Level Oyster Bar

Highlights
Excellent service
Delicious Lobster roll
Good clam chowder
Pretty view
Wide variety of seafood

Imagine dining in a restaurant with excellent service that leaves you completely immersed in the Halloween spirit. Sea Level Oyster Bar in Salem MA is the perfect spot to indulge in the festivities while cherishing their scrumptious delights.

Let's start by talking about their delicious Lobster roll. Oh boy, it's a wicked good treat! The succulent lobster meat, perfectly blended with the right amount of mayo, fills every bite with pure delight. It's a true taste of coastal New England heaven.

And let's not forget their good clam chowder. A warm bowl of this savory soup is like comfort in a cauldron. The rich flavors of fresh clams, creamy broth, and aromatic herbs will cast a spell over your taste buds.

While savoring their delectable dishes, take a moment to soak in the pretty view of the harbor. The soothing sight of the water gently splashing against the dock creates a mesmerizing ambiance, sprinkling a touch of magic to your dining experience.

Furthermore, Sea Level Oyster Bar offers a wide variety of seafood options for those craving more than just lobster. From perfectly seared scallops to tender crab cakes, they have something for every seafood lover.

Overall, Sea Level Oyster Bar in Salem MA offers a bewitching culinary experience with its delightful dishes, charming atmosphere, and friendly staff. So, if you find yourself in Salem during Halloween, don't miss the opportunity to indulge in their tantalizing treats.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Boston.

Blue Fez

Highlights
Delicious food
Friendly staff
Charming atmosphere
Fresh ingredients
Great vegetarian options

Blue Fez is a hidden gem that epitomizes the very essence of Halloween dining. Nestled in the heart of Salem MA, this charming restaurant offers an extraordinary culinary experience that will leave you spellbound.

Upon entering, I was immediately captivated by the charming atmosphere that seamlessly blended the rustic with the eerie. Dimly-lit lanterns illuminated the eclectic artwork adorning the walls, creating a mysterious yet inviting ambiance.

The menu at Blue Fez is a delightful fusion of flavors that cater to all palates. Each dish was expertly crafted with fresh ingredients and presented with artistic flair. From the moment the appetizers arrived, my taste buds were tantalized. The delicious food consistently exceeded my expectations, leaving me yearning for more.

What truly sets Blue Fez apart is their exceptional service. The friendly staff were knowledgeable, attentive, and went above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Their enthusiasm for Halloween was contagious, further enhancing the magical atmosphere.

Being a vegetarian, I was pleasantly surprised by the array of great vegetarian options available. The innovative combinations of flavors and textures showcased Blue Fez's commitment to catering to all dietary preferences.

In conclusion, if you're seeking a bewitching dining experience in Salem MA for Halloween, look no further than Blue Fez. With its delicious food, friendly staff, and hauntingly charming atmosphere, this enchanting restaurant is sure to leave you under its spell.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

O'Neills Pub & Restaurant

Highlights
Huge portion sizes
Live music and darts
Strong and flavorful drinks
Variety of enjoyable entrees
Great Irish curry meal

Let me start by saying, O'Neills Pub & Restaurant is a hidden gem in the heart of Salem, perfect for those seeking an unforgettable Halloween culinary adventure. From the moment I stepped foot inside, I knew I was in for a treat.

It's impossible to miss the huge portion sizes that O'Neills serves. Each dish is a feast for the eyes and a delight for the taste buds. Whether you're craving a hearty plate of fish and chips or a mouthwatering burger, this place truly knows how to satisfy any Halloween appetite.

What sets O'Neills apart from the rest is the lively atmosphere. With live music and darts available, this pub knows how to keep its guests entertained throughout their dining experience. The ambiance is infectiously festive, making it the perfect spot to celebrate Halloween with friends or family.

Speaking of celebrations, the strong and flavorful drinks at O'Neills are worth raising a glass to. Their bartenders are masters of mixology, serving up spooky-themed cocktails that are sure to delight even the pickiest of witches and warlocks.

One standout dish that I would highly recommend is their Irish curry meal. The combination of tender meat, fragrant spices, and creamy sauce is simply heavenly. It's the perfect way to warm up after a chilly night of Halloween festivities.

In conclusion, O'Neills Pub & Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in a truly memorable Halloween dining experience. With its variety of enjoyable entrees, lively ambiance, and all-around fantastic service, O'Neills has truly mastered the art of Halloween dining. Don't miss out on this deliciously spooky spot in Salem!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in Boston.

The Tavern

Highlights
Fantastic service
Delicious food
Old world charm
Cozy atmosphere
Great service

Upon entering The Tavern, I was immediately struck by its old world charm and cozy atmosphere. The rustic wooden furniture, dim lighting, and flickering candles on each table added to the spooky ambiance that is perfect for Halloween. The staff greeted me with smiles and were fantastically attentive throughout my entire visit, truly embodying the spirit of exceptional service.

Now let's talk about the food. Oh my, it was absolutely delicious! The menu showcased a delightful variety of dishes, from classic New England seafood to hearty comfort food. I opted for their signature pumpkin bisque, which was a decadent and perfectly spiced delight. The main course was a mouthwatering medley of flavors, as I savored their tender braised lamb shank with roasted root vegetables and garlic mashed potatoes. Every bite was like a culinary dance on my taste buds!

What set The Tavern apart from the other Halloween-themed restaurants I visited in Salem was not only the quality of the food but also the exceptional service. The waitstaff were knowledgeable about the menu and were quick to offer recommendations. They truly went above and beyond to ensure I had an exceptional dining experience.

In conclusion, The Tavern in Salem MA is a hidden gem that shines during Halloween. Its fantastic service, delicious food, old world charm, and cozy atmosphere make it the perfect spot to indulge in a spooky and scrumptious meal. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking to treat themselves during their visit to Salem MA for Halloween.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in Boston.

Village Tavern

Highlights
Gluten-free burgers
Vegan burgers
Clean bathroom
Excellent nachos
Fun Pub Trivia night

Village Tavern in Salem MA is a hidden gem that should be on every Halloween enthusiast's radar. As soon as I stepped in, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that perfectly captures the spooky spirit of Salem. The staff donned creative costumes, adding an extra touch of festivity to the evening.

Now, let's talk about the food. Village Tavern truly caters to all dietary preferences, offering a tantalizing selection of gluten-free and vegan burgers. As a gluten-free advocate myself, this was music to my ears. The juicy patties were cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor, leaving me craving for more.

One thing that sets Village Tavern apart is their commitment to cleanliness. I was delighted to find a spotless bathroom, ensuring a comfortable dining experience. It's a small detail that often goes unnoticed, but it truly made a difference in my visit.

As I sat at the bar, I couldn't resist ordering their famous nachos. And boy, they were exceptional! Loaded with gooey cheese, fresh toppings, and a generous helping of salsa, each bite was a heavenly delight.

But what really made my visit unforgettable was their fun Pub Trivia night. It was the perfect way to unwind and test my Halloween knowledge while enjoying some tasty treats. The friendly banter and competitive spirit created an electric atmosphere that kept me entertained until the very end.

Overall, Village Tavern is an absolute must-visit during the Halloween season in Salem MA. With their delectable burgers, impeccable cleanliness, and lively trivia nights, this restaurant offers a memorable experience that perfectly captures the spirit of Halloween.

You might also want to check out the best hot pot in Boston.

Longboards Restaurant & Bar

Highlights
Delicious seafood
Charming waterfront atmosphere
Unique French fries
Attentive and knowledgeable server
Outstanding flatbread

Longboards Restaurant & Bar in Salem MA is a hidden gem that should not be missed if you're looking for a spooktacular dining experience during Halloween season. As I entered the restaurant, I was greeted by a charming waterfront atmosphere that set the perfect mood for the evening.

For starters, I was in seafood heaven! Longboards offers a variety of mouthwatering seafood dishes that are truly a treat. From perfectly cooked scallops to succulent lobster, every bite was a delight. But what stole the show were their unique French fries. Crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, they were served with various flavorful sauces that added a whimsical twist to the dish.

The service at Longboards was top-notch. Our server was attentive and knowledgeable, providing helpful recommendations and making sure we had everything we needed. They were also well-versed in the history of Salem and shared fascinating local legends that added an extra touch of Halloween magic to our dining experience.

And let's not forget about the outstanding flatbread! Thin, crispy, and loaded with fresh ingredients, it was a delightful blend of flavors that left me wanting more.

Whether you're a seafood lover, a fan of spooky ambiance, or simply looking for a delightful dining experience during Halloween, Longboards Restaurant & Bar in Salem MA is an absolute must-visit. So grab your broomstick and fly on over for a hauntingly good time!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Cambridge.

Rockafellas Restaurant

Highlights
Amazing food
Spooky atmosphere
Friendly staff
Great location
Unique merchandise

Rockafellas Restaurant in Salem MA is the ultimate Halloween dining destination. From the moment you step inside, you are transported into a world of enchantment and mystique. The spooky atmosphere is evident in every detail, from the dimly lit interior to the hauntingly beautiful Halloween decorations adorning the walls.

But it's not just the ambiance that makes this place special; the food is absolutely amazing. Each dish is crafted with precision and care, offering a delectable fusion of flavors that will leave you bewitched. The menu boasts a wide selection of mouthwatering dishes, from savory pumpkin ravioli to tender Braised Beef Short Ribs.

The staff at Rockafellas truly go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. They are friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable, always ready to make recommendations or answer any questions you may have. Their passion for their work and dedication to providing exceptional service shines through in every interaction.

Located in the heart of Salem, the restaurant is perfectly positioned to allow guests to immerse themselves in the magic of Halloween. After a delicious meal, you can venture out and explore the haunted streets of Salem, experiencing the historic town's spooky allure.

And here's the icing on the cauldron-shaped cake - Rockafellas even offers unique merchandise for sale, so you can take a piece of Salem and the Halloween spirit home with you.

Overall, Rockafellas Restaurant in Salem MA is a must-visit for anyone seeking an unforgettable dining experience during Halloween. With its amazing food, spooky atmosphere, friendly staff, great location, and unique merchandise, it truly embodies the spirit of the season.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Boston.

Antique Table Restaurant

Highlights
Fantastic food
Pretty decor
Wonderful staff
Nice atmosphere
Delicious white pudding

The moment I walked into Antique Table Restaurant, I was immediately captivated by the pretty decor that created a cozy and inviting atmosphere. The tables were adorned with spooky yet elegant Halloween decorations, adding a playful touch to the ambience.

Now, let's talk about the fantastic food. Antique Table Restaurant offers a menu that perfectly combines classic Italian dishes with a Halloween twist. Being a fan of seafood, I decided to try their seafood linguine, and oh boy, it did not disappoint. The pasta was cooked to perfection and the seafood was incredibly fresh and flavorful. It was truly a treat for my taste buds.

I must also mention the wonderful staff who made my dining experience even better. They were attentive, friendly, and created a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Their knowledge of the menu was impressive, and they were more than happy to make recommendations based on my preferences.

Overall, my visit to Antique Table Restaurant was a delightful experience that exceeded my expectations. The combination of fantastic food, pretty decor, wonderful staff, and a nice atmosphere made it a top choice for Halloween dining.

And oh, before I forget, you absolutely cannot leave Antique Table without trying their delicious white pudding. It was the perfect ending to an already amazing meal.

So, if you find yourself in Salem MA during Halloween, I highly recommend paying a visit to Antique Table Restaurant. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best steak house in Boston.

99 Restaurants

Highlights
Open semi outside space
Hard-working waitress
Polite service
Cornhole game
Great service

Let me start by saying that 99 Restaurants offers a unique dining experience during the spooky season. As I stepped into the restaurant, I was immediately drawn to their open semi outside space, which perfectly captured the Halloween spirit.

The moment I sat down, I was greeted by a hard-working waitress who truly went above and beyond to ensure an enjoyable meal. Her polite service added a touch of professionalism to this playful setting.

One of the highlights of my evening was discovering that 99 Restaurants had set up a cornhole game outside. It was a fantastic addition, allowing patrons to engage in some friendly competition while savoring their delicious meals.

Speaking of meals, the food at 99 Restaurants did not disappoint. It was evident that the kitchen staff put in great effort to deliver scrumptious dishes that satisfied my cravings. Moreover, their service was unparalleled. With each visit to the table, the waitstaff continued to provide timely and courteous service, making me feel like a valued guest.

In conclusion, 99 Restaurants in Salem MA provided an excellent Halloween dining experience. From the open semi outside space, hard-working waitress, polite service, to the entertaining cornhole game, and delicious food, there was no shortage of highlights. If you're looking for a top-notch restaurant during Halloween season in Salem, make sure to add 99 Restaurants to your list!

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in Boston Chinatown.

Mercy Tavern

Highlights
Quick and accommodating staff
Delicious Spooky Juice
Amazing pumpkin ravioli
Fantastic lobster roll
Relaxing and hip ambiance

Mercy Tavern in Salem MA is a hidden gem that is perfect for those seeking a Halloween dining experience. Let me start by saying that the staff at Mercy Tavern is quick and accommodating, making you feel like a special guest from the moment you step foot inside.

To set the spooky mood, I highly recommend trying their signature Spooky Juice. This concoction is a delightful blend of mysterious flavors that will leave your taste buds tingling with excitement. A must-try for any Halloween enthusiast!

Now, let's talk about the main course. The pumpkin ravioli at Mercy Tavern is simply scrumptious. Each bite is bursting with flavors of fall, and the creamy sauce perfectly complements the delicate pasta. It truly is a match made in culinary heaven.

If seafood is more your style, don't miss out on their fantastic lobster roll. The fresh lobster meat is piled high on a buttery roll, creating a mouthwatering combination that will leave you wanting more.

Aside from the delectable food, Mercy Tavern also boasts a relaxing and hip atmosphere. The dimly lit dining area is adorned with spooky decorations, putting you in the perfect Halloween spirit.

Overall, Mercy Tavern is a must-visit restaurant in Salem MA for Halloween. With its quick and accommodating staff, delicious Spooky Juice, amazing pumpkin ravioli, and fantastic lobster rolls, this place manages to create an experience that is both playful and professional. So, gather your friends and head over to Mercy Tavern for a spooktacular dining experience!

You might also want to check out the best desserts in Boston.