The Absolute Best New York Style Pizza in Boston [Updated 2025]

Having tried and tested a staggering 15 pizza joints across the city, I am confident that this comprehensive guide will satisfy even the most discerning New York pizza lover. Each slice I devoured was meticulously assessed, ensuring that only the top contenders made it onto this prestigious list.

From the perfectly thin and crispy crust to the gooey cheese and tangy tomato sauce, I left no stone unturned in my quest to find the true essence of a New York pie right here in Boston. Join me on this delectable journey as we uncover the hidden gems that serve up the very best New York-style pizza in our beloved city.

Supreme Pizza

Highlights
Amazing food
Fast service
Affordable
Authentic taste

Let me start by saying that Supreme Pizza truly lives up to its name. From the moment I stepped into the cozy pizzeria, I could tell that I was in for a treat. The aroma of freshly baked pizzas filled the air, instantly making my mouth water in anticipation.

The highlights of my visit can be summed up in four words: amazing food, fast service, affordable prices, and authentic taste. Let me break it down for you.

First, the food. I ordered a classic cheese pizza, and it was absolutely divine. The crust was thin and delightfully crispy, just like a true New York style pizza should be. The cheese was perfectly melted and had just the right amount of stretchiness. And the tomato sauce? Bursting with flavor and tanginess. Each bite was a slice of heaven.

Next, the service. I was pleasantly surprised by how fast my pizza was prepared. The staff at Supreme Pizza worked like a well-oiled machine, ensuring that all customers received their orders promptly. They were friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about their menu, making the whole experience even more enjoyable.

Now, let's talk about the affordability. As someone who has tried numerous New York style pizzas in Boston, I must say that Supreme Pizza offers exceptional value for money. The prices are reasonable, especially considering the quality and portion sizes of their pizzas. It's a win-win.

Lastly, the authentic taste. Supreme Pizza truly captures the essence of New York style pizzas. Every bite took me back to the bustling streets of the Big Apple. The flavors were bold, the ingredients were fresh, and the overall taste was simply unforgettable.

In conclusion, Supreme Pizza in Boston is a hidden gem when it comes to the best New York style pizza. With its amazing food, fast service, affordable prices, and authentic taste, it's a must-visit for all pizza enthusiasts. So, grab a friend or two, head down to Supreme Pizza, and experience a slice of New York in the heart of Boston.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Boston.

Crispy Dough Pizzeria

Highlights
Best non-cheese pizza
Buffalo chicken pizza
Crispy honey pizza
BBQ chicken pizza
Great customer service

Crispy Dough Pizzeria in Boston truly impressed me with their wide range of mouthwatering pizza options. This eatery is a hidden gem for anyone searching for the best New York style pizza in the city.

One of the highlights of Crispy Dough Pizzeria is their variety of unique toppings. For those who prefer a break from traditional cheese pizza, I highly recommend trying their Buffalo chicken pizza. The perfectly crispy crust combined with a tangy buffalo sauce and tender chicken creates a flavor explosion that will leave your taste buds wanting more.

If you have a sweet tooth, don't miss out on their signature Crispy honey pizza. The perfect balance between sweet and savory, this pizza is topped with a drizzle of honey that caramelizes as it bakes, enhancing the flavors of the cheese and sauce. It's an unexpected combination that will leave you pleasantly surprised.

For those craving a classic favorite, their BBQ chicken pizza is a must-try. The tender chicken drenched in smoky barbecue sauce, paired with melted cheese and a crispy crust, delivers a satisfying and flavorful experience.

Apart from their delectable pizzas, the staff at Crispy Dough Pizzeria provides great customer service. They are friendly, efficient, and more than willing to help with any questions or special requests.

In conclusion, Crispy Dough Pizzeria is a true standout when it comes to New York style pizza in Boston. With their unique and delicious toppings, friendly staff, and cozy atmosphere, this pizzeria is worth every bite. So why wait? Head over to Crispy Dough Pizzeria and indulge in some irresistible slices that will transport you straight to the streets of New York.

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Boston.

Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar

Highlights
Friendly and attentive staff
Delicious prosciutto pizza
Great selection of desserts
Excellent wood-fired pizza
Convenient location in Fort Point

In my quest to find the best New York style pizza in Boston, I stumbled upon a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Fort Point. Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar immediately caught my attention with its trendy yet cozy ambiance. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly and attentive staff, which added to the overall warm and inviting atmosphere.

But let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza. Pastoral is renowned for its wood-fired creations, and boy, let me tell you, they did not disappoint. The pizzas are perfectly crisp with just the right amount of chewiness that defines authentic New York-style crust. Each bite transported me straight to the bustling streets of Manhattan.

Among their mouthwatering selection, the prosciutto pizza stole the spotlight for me. The combination of the savory prosciutto, creamy mozzarella, and tangy tomato sauce was a harmonious symphony of flavors. The generous toppings were expertly balanced, making this pizza a true masterpiece.

As a dessert enthusiast, I couldn't resist sampling their sweets, and I was pleasantly surprised by the great selection available. From traditional tiramisu to delectable chocolate hazelnut tart, they had something to satisfy every sweet tooth.

Adding to the allure, Pastoral's convenient location in Fort Point makes it easily accessible for both locals and tourists alike. Whether you're seeking a quick bite after work or a relaxed dinner with friends, this place has got you covered.

In conclusion, Pastoral ARTisan Pizza + Kitchen + Bar has truly mastered the art of crafting authentic New York-style pizza. Their delicious wood-fired creations, alongside a friendly staff and a convenient location, make for an unforgettable dining experience. If you're looking for a taste of the Big Apple in the heart of Boston, make sure to pay Pastoral a visit. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Boston.

New York Pizza

Highlights
Delicious
Unique flavors
Quick service

New York Pizza in Boston is a mouthwatering slice of joy that will transport you straight to the streets of New York City. As I embarked on my quest to find the best new york style pizza in Boston, this pizzeria stood out with its delicious pies and unique flavors.

The first thing that caught my attention was the tantalizing aroma that filled the air as I entered. It instantly made my mouth water with anticipation. The menu offered a wide variety of toppings, ranging from classic favorites to more adventurous options. Each slice was a work of art, with a perfect ratio of cheese to sauce and a thin, crispy crust that was just the right amount of chewy.

What really set New York Pizza apart from the competition was their commitment to quick service. Despite the crowd, the staff efficiently churned out piping hot slices with lightning speed. This was a lifesaver for hungry patrons looking for a quick, satisfying meal.

The flavors exploded in my mouth with every bite, showcasing the culinary prowess of the pizzaiolos behind New York Pizza. From the tanginess of the homemade tomato sauce to the gooeyness of the melted cheese, each ingredient worked harmoniously to create a flavor symphony.

After my visit to New York Pizza, I can confidently say that it is a must-visit for any pizza lover in Boston. Their dedication to delivering delicious pizzas with unique flavors and quick service is truly commendable. So, if you're craving a taste of the Big Apple in the heart of Boston, make sure to stop by New York Pizza for an unforgettable experience.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Worcester.

Ernesto's Pizza

Highlights
Large slices
Excellent cheese
Perfect dough
Savory sweetness

Upon entering Ernesto's Pizza, I was immediately drawn to the large slices of pizza on display. The sight alone was enough to make my mouth water in anticipation. As I took my first bite, I was blown away by the excellent cheese, which was perfectly melted and oozing with flavor. The cheese had a savoriness that complemented the rest of the toppings beautifully.

The dough at Ernesto's Pizza was truly something special. It had just the right amount of chewiness and crispiness. With each bite, I could taste the expertise that went into crafting the perfect dough. It was a delight to sink my teeth into.

One thing that set Ernesto's Pizza apart from the rest was its unique touch of savory sweetness. Their sauce had a subtle hint of sweetness that added depth and complexity to the overall taste. It balanced perfectly with the savory flavors of the cheese and toppings, creating a harmonious blend of flavors in every bite.

The ambiance at Ernesto's Pizza was cozy and welcoming. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, making the experience even more enjoyable. The combination of delicious pizza and a warm atmosphere made me feel like I was dining at a beloved New York pizzeria in the heart of Boston.

In conclusion, Ernesto's Pizza is a must-visit for anyone searching for the best New York style pizza in Boston. From the large slices to the excellent cheese, the perfect dough, and the savory sweetness, every element comes together to create a pizza experience that is simply outstanding.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Plymouth MI.

FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca

Highlights
Amazing pizza
Humongous slices
Busy and popular
Fantastic taste
Craving for more

Let me start by saying, the pizza at FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca was absolutely amazing! From the moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked dough filled the air, making my mouth water uncontrollably.

The slices here are humongous! I was pleasantly surprised by the generous size of each slice. One slice was almost like a mini meal in itself. It's safe to say that no one leaves FLORINA's feeling hungry.

This place is always busy and popular, and for good reason. The locals know that FLORINA's is the go-to spot for authentic New York style pizza in Boston. Being surrounded by other pizza enthusiasts waiting their turn, only heightened my excitement and anticipation.

But it was the taste that truly won me over. FLORINA's pizza was fantastic. The perfect combination of a crispy yet chewy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, leaving me wanting more.

I must admit, even after devouring an entire slice (or two), I found myself craving for more. FLORINA's had that addictive quality, where you just can't resist going back for seconds. And thirds.

All in all, FLORINA Pizzeria & Paninoteca is a must-visit for any pizza lover in Boston. Their amazing pizza, humongous slices, and fantastic taste make it a top contender for the best New York style pizza in the city.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in Boston.

Boston Kitchen Pizza

Highlights
Huge honey chicken slice
Affordable and filling
Grilled buffalo chicken wrap
Fast food prep and delivery
Fresh ingredients

As I walked into Boston Kitchen Pizza, I immediately noticed the huge honey chicken slice on display. It was the perfect blend of sweet and savory, with tender chicken and a drizzle of honey that added a delightful touch to every bite.

The prices at Boston Kitchen Pizza were surprisingly affordable, especially considering the generous portion sizes. I left feeling satisfied and full without breaking the bank.

In addition to the pizza, I tried their grilled buffalo chicken wrap and was blown away by the spicy flavor and tender chicken. It was a refreshing twist on a classic dish and left me craving for more.

What impressed me the most about Boston Kitchen Pizza was the speed at which they prepared and delivered their food. Despite the bustling atmosphere, I received my order in no time without compromising the quality of the food.

The fresh ingredients shone through in every bite, from the flavorful sauce to the perfectly melted cheese. Each slice was a testament to the care and attention to detail that goes into making a great New York style pizza.

In conclusion, Boston Kitchen Pizza is a must-visit for anyone in Boston searching for the best New York style pizza. The combination of affordable prices, delicious flavors, and fast service makes it a standout choice among the competition.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in Boston.

Union Park Pizza

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming
Accommodates dietary needs
Fresh and flavorful pizza
Excellent customer service
Convenient location

Walking into Union Park Pizza, I was immediately struck by the friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The staff greeted me with warm smiles as I approached the counter, ready to embark on my pizza-tasting adventure.

One thing that stood out to me about Union Park Pizza is their commitment to accommodating dietary needs. As a vegetarian, I appreciate when restaurants go the extra mile to cater to different preferences. Their menu boasted a wide variety of veggie toppings, allowing me to customize my own perfect New York-style slice.

Now, let's talk about the pizza itself. The first bite immediately transported me to the bustling streets of New York City. The crust was thin and crispy, just as it should be. The cheese was perfectly melted, creating a gooey sensation with each mouthwatering bite. And the sauce! Oh, the sauce was a symphony of flavors, tangy yet subtly sweet.

Aside from the incredible flavors, Union Park Pizza impressed me with their excellent customer service. The staff was attentive and genuinely passionate about their craft, making sure each customer had an exceptional experience.

Conveniently located, Union Park Pizza is a hidden gem in the heart of Boston. So, if you find yourself craving an authentic New York style pizza, make sure to pay them a visit. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best hot pot in Boston.

Blaze Pizza

Highlights
Generous toppings
Flavorful pizzas
Fast and friendly service

Blaze Pizza truly made a blazing impression on me with their deliciously crafted pizzas. The generous toppings on their New York style pizzas were truly a sight to behold. Each bite was a burst of flavors that left me craving for more.

What stood out the most about Blaze Pizza, aside from their delectable pizzas, was their fast and friendly service. The staff was incredibly attentive, guiding me through the process of customizing my own pizza to perfection. They took their time to make sure that my pizza was made exactly to my liking, ensuring every ingredient was placed with care.

The first bite into the crust was a revelation. It had the perfect balance of chewiness and crispness, just like a true New York style pizza. The thin crust was able to hold the copious amounts of toppings I had requested without getting soggy. From the tangy tomato sauce to the gooey mozzarella cheese, every ingredient melded together harmoniously.

Blaze Pizza has truly captured the essence of what a New York style pizza should be. The combination of their flavorful pizzas, generous toppings, and exceptional service makes them a strong contender for the title of the best New York style pizza in Boston.

If you're a pizza lover like me and want a taste of authentic New York style pizza in the heart of Boston, be sure to check out Blaze Pizza. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Cambridge.

Sal's Pizza | Tremont Street | Boston, MA

Highlights
Damn good pizza
Large portions at reasonable price
Great service
Quiet atmosphere

Let me start by saying, wow, I was blown away by the damn good pizza at Sal's Pizza on Tremont Street in Boston. This place is a hidden gem when it comes to New York style pizza.

First and foremost, the pizza itself is incredible. The thin, crispy crust is reminiscent of the authentic New York slices I've had in the Big Apple. Topped with just the right amount of rich tomato sauce and gooey cheese, every bite is a burst of flavors that will transport you to the streets of Manhattan.

One thing that stood out to me was the generous portions offered at Sal's. You certainly won't leave hungry, as their slices are as big as your face. And the best part? The prices are more than reasonable for the quality and quantity you receive. It's a win-win!

Now, let's talk about the service. The staff at Sal's Pizza were friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. They provided top-notch recommendations and were quick to address any inquiries I had. Their hospitality truly elevated the dining experience.

The atmosphere at Sal's is also worth mentioning. Despite being located in a bustling city like Boston, the restaurant managed to create a quiet and relaxed ambiance. It's the perfect spot to grab a quick lunch or unwind after a long day.

In conclusion, if you're searching for the best New York style pizza in Boston, look no further than Sal's Pizza on Tremont Street. With their damn good pizza, large portions at a reasonable price, great service, and quiet atmosphere, it's an experience you won't want to miss. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Boston.

Picco

Highlights
Wide selection of draft beers
Slightly more robust New York style pizza
Light airy crust
Delicious homemade peanut butter and dark chocolate chip ice cream
Attentive and excellent server

Let me start off by saying, wow! The moment I walked into Picco, I was immediately drawn to their wide selection of draft beers. As a pizza lover, what could be better than enjoying a cold pint of beer alongside a slice of delicious New York style pizza?

Speaking of the pizza, Picco did not disappoint. Their New York style pizza had a slightly more robust flavor than what you typically find in Boston. It was like a flavor explosion in my mouth! And let me tell you about the crust. It was light and airy, perfectly balanced with just the right amount of chewiness.

But the delights didn't stop there. For dessert, I indulged in their homemade peanut butter and dark chocolate chip ice cream. Oh boy, it was a decadent treat that I couldn't resist. The combination of creamy peanut butter and rich dark chocolate chips was a match made in heaven.

Lastly, I want to mention the attentive and excellent server who made my dining experience even more enjoyable. Their recommendations and knowledge of the menu truly enhanced my visit.

All in all, Picco is a must-visit destination for all pizza enthusiasts in Boston. With their wide selection of draft beers, slightly more robust New York style pizza, light airy crust, and delicious homemade ice cream, Picco truly stands out among the rest. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you for experiencing the magic at Picco.

New Market Pizza

Highlights
Fresh pizza
Crispy veggies
Good combos
Huge slices
Friendly staff

Let me start by saying, the fresh pizza at New Market Pizza was an absolute delight! The moment I walked in, I was greeted with the aroma of freshly baked dough, tickling my taste buds and making my stomach rumble with anticipation.

The first thing that caught my attention was their crispy veggies. The toppings were perfectly sliced and had that satisfying crunch with every bite. Whether it was the vibrant green peppers, juicy tomatoes, or tangy onions, each vegetable added a burst of flavor that complemented the pizza perfectly.

I must mention the great combos they offer. The Margherita was a classic that melted in my mouth, and The Works took my taste buds on a wild adventure with its combination of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and olives. The range of options made it difficult to choose just one, but I was definitely not disappointed with my pick.

Now let's talk about the slices. Oh boy, these slices were enormous! It was like holding a whole pizza in my hand. They were bigger than my face! I couldn't help but marvel at the size and generous toppings that covered each gigantic slice. One slice was definitely enough to satisfy even the hungriest of appetites.

Lastly, I have to mention the friendly staff. They were attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about their pizzas. Their recommendations were spot-on and they made every customer feel like a valued guest. It truly added to the overall experience.

In conclusion, New Market Pizza in Boston offers a truly authentic New York style pizza experience. From the freshness of their ingredients to the crispy veggies and good combos, every aspect of their pizza was top-notch. The huge slices and friendly staff were the icing on the cake. So, if you're in Boston and craving a slice of the Big Apple, New Market Pizza should be at the top of your list.

The Upper Crust Pizzeria

Highlights
Best pizza
Chicken tenders
Great for the money
Helpful staff
BBQ chicken wings

Let me start by saying, wow, The Upper Crust Pizzeria truly knows how to deliver a spectacular new york style pizza. As I sunk my teeth into their delectable creation, I couldn't help but be in awe of the perfect balance between the thin, crispy crust and the flavorful toppings. It was without a doubt one of the best pizzas I have ever tasted in Boston.

But wait, there's more! The Upper Crust Pizzeria also surprised me with their delectable chicken tenders. These crispy delights were cooked to perfection, providing an extra dose of indulgence to my meal. Not to mention, their helpful staff was prompt in taking my order and ensuring my dining experience was delightful from start to finish.

What impressed me even more was the incredible value for money that The Upper Crust Pizzeria offers. This hidden gem provides high-quality, authentic new york style pizzas that won't break the bank. Trust me, it's worth every penny.

While you're there, don't forget to try their BBQ chicken wings. These succulent bites are sure to please even the most discerning palate.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best new york style pizza in Boston, look no further than The Upper Crust Pizzeria. From their mouthwatering pizza to their tempting chicken tenders, this pizza joint is a definite winner. Don't just take my word for it, go and experience it for yourself!

Locale

Highlights
Spinach pizza is awesome
Cocktails are quite strong
Only salad and pizza options
Madeline provides excellent service
The Bianco is a must-try dish

The first thing that caught my attention at Locale was their Spinach pizza. Let me tell you, it was awesome. The crust had that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, and the toppings were flavorful and generous. It truly had that authentic New York style taste.

Now, let's talk about their drink selection. Locale takes their cocktails seriously, and they don't hold back on the alcohol. If you're looking for a strong sip to accompany your pizza, you won't be disappointed here. Just make sure you pace yourself!

Speaking of pizza, it's worth noting that the menu at Locale is focused solely on salads and pizzas. While some might consider this a limitation, I found it refreshing. Sometimes, you just want a place that specializes in what they do best, and that's exactly what Locale delivers.

But what truly sets Locale apart is their exceptional service. During my visit, I had the pleasure of being attended by Madeline, who provided excellent service with a warm and friendly attitude. Her recommendations were spot-on, and she made sure everything was to my liking.

Last but not least, if you visit Locale, do not miss out on trying their signature dish, The Bianco. It's a heavenly combination of prosciutto, ricotta, arugula, and truffle oil. The flavors melt together in a harmonious symphony that will leave you wanting more.

Overall, Locale in Boston is a place where you can indulge in an excellent New York style pizza while enjoying strong cocktails and outstanding service. So, if you're in the mood for a playful yet professional pizza experience, Locale should definitely be on your list.

Regina Pizzeria

Highlights
Excellent sausage pizza
Fresh and well-prepared salad
Affordable prices
Amazing customer service

Let me start by saying, if you're looking for an excellent slice of new york style pizza in Boston, look no further than Regina Pizzeria. This hidden gem truly knows how to deliver a pizza that transports you straight to the streets of New York City.

My taste buds were treated to an absolute delight when I tried their sausage pizza. The flavor was outstanding, with the perfect balance of savory sausage, tangy tomato sauce, and gooey melted cheese. Every bite was a harmonious symphony of flavors that left me wanting more.

But it wasn't just the pizza that impressed me. Regina Pizzeria also offers a range of fresh and well-prepared salads. The ingredients were vibrant and bursting with flavor, making for a refreshing accompaniment to the main event.

What sets Regina Pizzeria apart from the competition is their reasonable prices. It's clear that they prioritize providing quality food at affordable rates. As a pizza enthusiast on a budget, I couldn't be happier.

Lastly, I have to commend the staff for their amazing customer service. From the moment I walked through the door, I was greeted with warm smiles and prompt assistance. The team at Regina Pizzeria truly knows how to make their customers feel valued and appreciated.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best new york style pizza in Boston, Regina Pizzeria is a must-visit. Their excellent sausage pizza, fresh salads, affordable prices, and outstanding customer service make for an unforgettable dining experience. Don't miss out on this slice of New York City right here in Boston!