Plymouth's Best Lobster Roll [Updated 2024]

With my extensive knowledge and love for lobster rolls, I have had the pleasure of reviewing 15 different establishments in Plymouth. From charming seaside shacks to upscale restaurants, I have explored every nook and cranny of this historic coastal town to bring you the most comprehensive list. Prepare yourself for mouthwatering descriptions and delightful experiences because this guide will take you on a tantalizing journey through perfectly toasted buttered buns, succulent chunks of fresh lobster meat, and the perfect blend of seasonings. So, whether you're a local or a visitor craving a taste of New England's finest, this article promises to reveal the top spot for the best lobster roll in Plymouth.

The Blue-Eyed Crab Caribbean Grill & Rum Bar

Highlights
Excellent food, drinks, & service
Delicious banana garlic wings
Beautiful outdoor patio facing the water
Fantastic rum cake
Plenty of free parking

Let me start by saying that this place has it all – excellent food, drinks, and service. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and seated on their beautiful outdoor patio facing the water.

After scanning the menu, I couldn't resist trying their banana garlic wings. Trust me when I say, these wings were a flavor explosion in my mouth. The combination of sweet banana and savory garlic was pure genius. It was a truly unique and delightful appetizer.

Now onto the main event – the lobster roll. And let me tell you, The Blue-Eyed Crab did not disappoint. The lobster meat was fresh, tender, and overflowing from the buttery bun. The roll was perfectly seasoned, letting the natural sweetness of the lobster shine through. It was a true culinary masterpiece.

To top off my meal, I couldn't resist trying their fantastic rum cake. The moist cake infused with rich rum flavor was the perfect ending to my seafood feast.

Not only is the food at The Blue-Eyed Crab top-notch, but the service was impeccable. The staff was attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about their menu. They made sure that my dining experience was nothing short of extraordinary.

Oh, and one more thing – free parking! Plenty of it. A true rarity in Plymouth.

If you're in search of the best lobster roll in Plymouth, look no further than The Blue-Eyed Crab Caribbean Grill & Rum Bar. It's a hidden gem that promises an incredible dining experience with delicious food, refreshing drinks, and unparalleled service.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Boston.

Alden Park

Highlights
On point food
Nice specialty cocktails
Friendly and attentive staff
Beautiful and quiet restaurant
Prompt and divine service

Let me start by saying that the lobster roll at Alden Park is truly a masterpiece. From the moment I walked into the restaurant, I was impressed by its beautiful and quiet ambiance. The staff immediately greeted me with a warm smile and seated me at a cozy table.

As I perused the menu, I noticed that Alden Park not only offers an impressive selection of seafood dishes, but also has a nice variety of specialty cocktails. I couldn't resist ordering a refreshing drink to complement my lobster roll.

When the lobster roll arrived at the table, I was instantly captivated by its presentation. The roll was filled to perfection with tender, juicy lobster meat, tossed in just the right amount of mayo and seasoning. The lobster was so fresh and succulent that every bite was like a burst of flavor in my mouth. It was evident that the chefs at Alden Park know how to make an on point lobster roll.

What impressed me the most, however, was the friendly and attentive service provided by the staff. They made sure that my dining experience was top-notch, attending to my needs promptly and with a smile.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best lobster roll in Plymouth, I highly recommend giving Alden Park a try. Their lobster roll is a true masterpiece, accompanied by a divine dining experience. Your taste buds will thank you for it.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Quincy Market.

Pebbles

Highlights
Delicious Fish
Tasty Chowder
Large Portions
Friendly Staff
Beautiful Ocean View

My taste buds were sent on a delightful adventure at Pebbles in Plymouth. The moment I sank my teeth into their lobster roll, I was transported to seafood heaven. The lobster meat was tender, succulent, and bursting with flavors. It was a moment of pure gastronomic bliss.

Aside from their delicious fish, Pebbles also offers a tasty chowder that left me craving for more. The creamy broth was perfectly seasoned, and every spoonful was like a warm hug on a chilly day. And oh, the portions they serve! I've had my fair share of lobster rolls, but Pebbles truly takes it to the next level with their generous serving size.

What really stood out to me was the friendly staff at Pebbles. From the moment I stepped foot into the restaurant, I felt welcomed and well taken care of. Their genuine smiles and attentive service added an extra layer of enjoyment to my dining experience.

And let's not forget the beautiful ocean view that Pebbles offers. As I savored every bite of my lobster roll, I couldn't help but be mesmerized by the sight of the sparkling blue waters. It was the perfect backdrop to an already amazing meal.

In conclusion, Pebbles in Plymouth is a must-visit for any lobster roll enthusiast. With their delicious fish, tasty chowder, large portions, friendly staff, and a view that takes your breath away, it's clear why Pebbles is a standout in the Plymouth dining scene.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Salem.

The CabbyShack

Highlights
Awesome food
Nice views
Amazing chowder
Huge portions
Fantastic dishes

Let me start by saying, The CabbyShack in Plymouth truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best spots for a delightful lobster roll experience!

When it comes to the highlights, this place knocks it out of the park. First and foremost, the food is awesome. From the moment I took my first bite of their lobster roll, I knew I had stumbled upon something special. The succulent lobster meat was impeccably fresh, tender, and full of flavor. It was nestled in a perfectly toasted and buttered split-top roll that added just the right amount of crunch. Pure perfection.

What sets The CabbyShack apart is not just the amazing lobster roll, but the overall dining experience. As a lobster roll enthusiast, I find that ambiance and views can greatly enhance the enjoyment of a meal. And let me tell you, this place delivers on both fronts. The restaurant overlooks the picturesque waterfront, providing a lovely backdrop while you savor your lobster roll.

As I delved further into their menu, I couldn't resist trying their renowned clam chowder. Oh my, it was absolutely amazing. Rich, creamy, and bursting with the flavors of the sea. It was the perfect starter to complement the lobster roll extravaganza that was about to unfold.

Furthermore, it's worth mentioning the huge portions that The CabbyShack offers. If you’re someone who loves their lobster as much as I do, you'll be thrilled with the generous serving sizes. Every bite is a scrumptious delight that leaves you feeling thoroughly satisfied.

All in all, The CabbyShack is a fantastic choice for anyone seeking the best lobster roll experience in Plymouth. With their dedication to excellent food, gorgeous views, and unforgettable dishes, it's no surprise that this restaurant consistently delivers. So, if you find yourself in Plymouth and you're craving a lobster roll that will leave you grinning from ear to ear, make sure to make your way to The CabbyShack!

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Boston Quincy Market.

East Bay Grille

Highlights
Good family atmosphere
Great view outside
Amazing seafood dish
Excellent service

I must say, East Bay Grille provided a good family atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The cheerful ambiance and friendly staff immediately put me at ease. And let me tell you, the great view outside only added to the dining experience. Who doesn't love enjoying a delicious lobster roll with a picturesque backdrop?

Now, let's talk about the main event—the amazing seafood dish. As a self-proclaimed lobster roll connoisseur, I had high expectations, and East Bay Grille did not disappoint. The lobster roll was a work of art. The perfectly toasted buttered bun held an abundant serving of succulent lobster meat, lightly seasoned with just the right amount of mayonnaise and spices. Each bite was a savory delight, with the lobster meat melt-in-your-mouth tender.

To top it all off, the service at East Bay Grille was excellent. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and quick to offer suggestions or answer any questions I had about the menu.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best lobster roll in Plymouth, do yourself a favor and head on over to East Bay Grille. With its good family atmosphere, great view outside, amazing seafood dish, and excellent service, this place is a lobster lover's paradise. Don't miss out on this delightful dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Cambridge.

Tavern On The Wharf

Highlights
Busy Friday night
Excellent service
Wide gluten free menu
Accommodating hostess
Attentive server

I arrived at Tavern On The Wharf on a bustling Friday night, eager to sample their renowned lobster roll. From the moment I stepped inside, I was taken aback by the excellent service provided. The staff greeted me with warm smiles and were quick to seat me at a cozy table with a stunning view of the waterfront.

As a writer with specific dietary needs, I was delighted to discover that Tavern On The Wharf offered a wide gluten-free menu, ensuring that all patrons could indulge in their culinary delights. The accommodating hostess went out of her way to address my requirements and promptly provided me with a gluten-free roll for my lobster creation.

Without further ado, my attentive server approached me and took my order. It didn't take long for my eagerly awaited lobster roll to arrive, and oh boy, was it worth the wait! The roll was perfectly toasted, with a generous amount of tender and succulent lobster meat. The lobster was seasoned to perfection, creating a harmonious balance of flavors that danced on my taste buds.

Despite the restaurant being busy, the Tavern On The Wharf staff never wavered in their commitment to providing exceptional service. From start to finish, it was clear that they had mastered the art of creating a memorable dining experience.

In conclusion, Tavern On The Wharf truly impressed me with their busy Friday night, excellent service, wide gluten-free menu, accommodating hostess, and attentive server. If you're in Plymouth and seeking the best lobster roll experience, look no further than Tavern On The Wharf. They are a true gem in Plymouth's culinary landscape.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Boston North End.

Wood's Seafood

Highlights
Family owned and operated
Fresh seafood from the harbor
Reasonably priced
Great clam chowder
Lobsters cooked fresh from the tank

Wood's Seafood is a hidden gem located in Plymouth that truly values the importance of family. Being family owned and operated, Wood's Seafood offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes you feel like a part of their family from the moment you step foot through the door.

But let's talk about the main event - their lobster rolls. When it comes to serving up the freshest seafood, Wood's Seafood definitely knows what they're doing. Their lobsters are cooked fresh from the tank, ensuring that every bite is filled with succulent and tender meat. The lobster rolls are piled high with generous portions of lobster, making it a delight for any seafood lover.

One aspect that I particularly loved about Wood's Seafood is their commitment to affordability. Despite serving top-notch lobster rolls, they manage to keep their prices reasonably priced. You won't have to break the bank to indulge in this delectable seafood experience.

While the lobster rolls are the star of the show, I must also mention their clam chowder. Creamy, flavorful, and packed with juicy clams, this chowder is truly a showstopper.

In conclusion, Wood's Seafood is truly a standout in Plymouth's culinary scene. From their fresh seafood sourced straight from the local harbor to their warm and welcoming environment, this family-owned establishment has all the qualities of a classic seafood joint. So, if you're on the hunt for the best lobster roll in Plymouth, don't hesitate to make your way to Wood's Seafood - a place where great food and family traditions come together in perfect harmony.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Boston.

Sandy's

Highlights
Cash only option
Fried seafood
Oceanfront seating
Great ocean view

Let me start by saying, if you're looking for a playfully delicious experience, Sandy's is the place to be. This cozy little spot offers a cash only option, which adds to its charming, old-fashioned vibe.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the lobster roll. Sandy's offers a top-notch lobster roll that is sure to melt in your mouth. The generous amount of tender, succulent lobster meat is perfectly balanced with just a hint of mayo, allowing the true flavor of the lobster to shine through. It is a true masterpiece of culinary delight.

But Sandy's is not just about lobster rolls. Their fried seafood options are equally impressive. From crispy calamari to mouthwatering clam strips, each bite is a burst of flavor that will transport you to the oceanfront.

Speaking of oceanfront, Sandy's offers spectacular oceanfront seating. Imagine enjoying your lobster roll while gazing out at the breathtaking view of the ocean. It's the perfect setting to feel the coastal breeze and indulge in the ultimate seafood experience.

So if you're looking for a playful yet professional spot to enjoy the best lobster roll in Plymouth, make sure to visit Sandy's. Whether it's the cash-only option or the fried seafood, every aspect of this place is designed to make your taste buds dance with joy. Don't miss out on this hidden gem!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Boston.

The Shanty Rose

Highlights
Great deal
50 cent wing day
Perfectly crispy wings
Lovely location

Nestled in the heart of Plymouth, The Shanty Rose is a hidden gem that takes lobster rolls to a whole new level. From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The cozy and inviting atmosphere instantly put me at ease, setting the stage for a truly enjoyable dining experience.

As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the great deal they offered on their lobster rolls. It was clear that The Shanty Rose takes pride in offering their customers quality food at affordable prices. The lobster roll was generously filled with succulent chunks of fresh lobster meat, nestled in a buttery roll that was toasted to perfection. Each bite was a harmony of flavors, with the sweet lobster meat blending seamlessly with the rich buttery notes.

But what really set The Shanty Rose apart were their 50 cent wing days. Who could resist such a tempting offer? I had to give it a try, and I was not disappointed. The wings were expertly cooked, perfectly crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. The variety of flavors available ensured that there was something for everyone, from tangy buffalo to savory garlic parmesan.

Beyond the delectable food, The Shanty Rose boasts a lovely location, which adds to the overall charm of the dining experience. Whether enjoying your meal inside the cozy restaurant or on their outdoor patio, you are treated to breathtaking views of Plymouth, creating a picturesque backdrop for your lobster roll feast.

The Shanty Rose is a delightful spot that excels in serving amazing lobster rolls. With their great deals and flavorful wings, it's a place that offers both quality and value. If you're on the hunt for the best lobster roll in Plymouth, The Shanty Rose is definitely a must-visit destination.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Boston.

Waterfront Bar and Grill

Highlights
Accommodating and friendly
Delicious gluten-free roll
Amazing cocktails and oysters
Generous portion of lobster
Excellent service

Let me start off by saying that the staff at Waterfront Bar and Grill are incredibly accommodating and friendly. From the moment I stepped foot in the restaurant, I felt welcomed and taken care of.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the lobster roll. Waterfront Bar and Grill offers a delightful twist for those with dietary restrictions – a delicious gluten-free roll. Finally, those who are gluten intolerant can indulge in the bliss of a perfectly crafted lobster roll without any worries. The roll itself was light and fluffy, providing the perfect vessel for the succulent lobster meat.

As a seafood enthusiast, I couldn't resist trying some oysters and boy, was I in for a treat! Waterfront Bar and Grill boasts an impressive selection of oysters that perfectly complemented my lobster roll. The amazing cocktails they offer were the cherry on top of an already outstanding dining experience.

One thing that truly stood out was the generous portion of lobster. Every bite was packed with tender and flavorful chunks of lobster, making it a truly satisfying meal. It's clear that Waterfront Bar and Grill doesn't skimp on quality or quantity when it comes to their lobster rolls.

Lastly, I must commend the excellent service I received throughout my visit. The staff were attentive and knowledgeable, ensuring that my dining experience was top-notch.

In conclusion, Waterfront Bar and Grill in Plymouth is a must-visit for lobster roll aficionados. With their accommodating and friendly staff, delicious gluten-free roll, amazing cocktails and oysters, generous portion of lobster, and excellent service, they truly deserve a spot on the list of the best lobster rolls in Plymouth.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Worcester.

Rock Bottom Seafood

Highlights
Fantastic customer service
Delicious food
Adorable and immaculate location
Extensive seafood selection
Easy pickup process

Let me start off by saying that Rock Bottom Seafood truly exceeded my expectations! From the moment I entered the establishment, I was greeted with fantastic customer service that made me feel like a valued guest.

The lobster roll at Rock Bottom Seafood was a work of art. Bursting with fresh and succulent lobster meat, each bite was a burst of sea-salty heaven. The perfectly toasted bun added just the right amount of texture to the dish. The impeccable balance of flavors made it a delicious experience that left me craving for more.

The location itself was simply adorable and immaculate. I couldn't help but admire the cozy atmosphere and attention to detail in its decorations. The coastal charm intensified my anticipation for the lobster roll, and I was not disappointed.

What truly impressed me about Rock Bottom Seafood, aside from the fabulous lobster roll, was their extensive seafood selection. From oysters to shrimp, there were plenty of options to satisfy any seafood lover. The quality and freshness of the ingredients were palpable in every bite.

Ordering at Rock Bottom Seafood was a breeze with their easy pickup process. They made sure that I received my order promptly, even during busy hours. The efficiency of their service left me with a smile on my face as I savored my lobster roll.

In conclusion, Rock Bottom Seafood in Plymouth is a hidden gem that leaves a lasting impression. Their dedication to providing excellent customer service, delicious food, and a delightful atmosphere make them a top contender for the best lobster roll in Plymouth. Don't miss out on this culinary experience!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Plymouth MI.

Anna's Harborside Grille

Highlights
Amazing food
Great atmosphere
Greek dishes
Greek pita bread
Great service

Located in the heart of Plymouth, Anna's Harborside Grille is a hidden gem for seafood lovers seeking the ultimate lobster roll. As I stepped foot into the restaurant, the great atmosphere immediately caught my attention, with its charming coastal decor and warm, friendly staff.

But let's talk about the star of the show – the lobster roll. Oh boy, it was a game-changer! From the moment it arrived at my table, I knew I was in for a treat. The lobster meat was fresh, succulent, and generously portioned, perfectly tucked into a buttery, toasted roll. The combination of flavors was simply exquisite – a delightful mix of tender lobster, tangy mayo, and a hint of lemon, danced on my taste buds. Every bite was a heavenly experience.

To my surprise, Anna's Harborside Grille goes beyond just lobster rolls. They also offer an array of Greek dishes that will transport you straight to the Mediterranean. One standout feature is their Greek pita bread, which is so fluffy and flavorful, you won't be able to resist tearing it apart. Whether you're a fan of seafood or not, Anna's Harborside Grille has something to satisfy every palate.

What impressed me just as much as the food was the great service. The staff at Anna's Harborside Grille were attentive, knowledgeable, and went above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience.

If you're in Plymouth and craving an exceptional lobster roll, look no further than Anna's Harborside Grille. With their amazing food, great atmosphere, and a touch of Greek culinary magic, they have truly earned their spot among the top contenders for the best lobster roll in town.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in Boston.

42º North Restaurant

Highlights
Delicious seafood
Indoor and outdoor seating
Tasty sides
Huge portions
Friendly bartender

Let me begin by saying, if you're looking for a place that serves delicious seafood in a vibrant atmosphere, look no further than 42º North Restaurant in Plymouth!

The first thing that caught my attention was the variety of seating options. They have both indoor and outdoor seating, allowing you to enjoy your meal in the setting that suits your mood. On a beautiful sunny day, I highly recommend grabbing a table on their outdoor patio to soak up some Vitamin D while indulging in their delectable lobster roll.

Speaking of the lobster roll, let me tell you, it was a dream come true! The roll itself was perfectly toasted, giving it a slight crunch that beautifully complemented the tender and flavorful lobster meat. But what I truly appreciated were the huge portions they served. I felt like royalty as I devoured each satisfying bite.

Now, let's not forget about the sides. The restaurant does an exceptional job of offering a variety of options to accompany their lobster roll. From crisp and refreshing salads to perfectly cooked fries, every side dish was a delightful addition to the meal.

Lastly, I have to give a shout-out to the friendly bartender who took care of me throughout my visit. Their impeccable service paired with their knowledge of the menu truly enhanced my dining experience.

In conclusion, for a lobster roll experience that will leave you yearning for more, make your way to 42º North Restaurant in Plymouth. With their delicious seafood, indoor and outdoor seating options, tasty sides, and of course, their generous portions, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in Boston.

Martini's Bar & Grill

Highlights
Appealing menu
A+ service
Delicious food
Great value
Nice window seat

Let me start by saying that Martini's Bar & Grill is a true hidden gem when it comes to finding the best lobster roll in Plymouth. From the moment I walked in, my eyes were immediately drawn to the appealing menu that offered a variety of mouthwatering seafood options.

The service I received at Martini's was nothing short of remarkable – it definitely deserves an A+! The staff was attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. They were more than happy to answer any questions I had and even provided recommendations to make my lobster roll experience even more enjoyable.

When my lobster roll arrived at the table, my senses were overwhelmed by the delightful aroma and vibrant colors of the dish. The lobster meat was incredibly juicy and flavorful, perfectly complemented by the buttery toasted roll. Each bite was a burst of oceanic goodness that left me craving for more.

What made my experience at Martini's even better was the great value they offer. The portion size was generous, and the price was very reasonable considering the quality of the ingredients and the skill of the chef.

To top it all off, I had the pleasure of sitting at a nice window seat that provided a lovely view of the picturesque Plymouth harbor. The combination of delectable food and a serene atmosphere made my visit to Martini's Bar & Grill truly memorable.

If you're in Plymouth and searching for the best lobster roll, look no further than Martini's Bar & Grill. Their delicious food, A+ service, and great value will satisfy your seafood cravings and leave you wanting to come back for more.

You might also want to check out the best hot pot in Boston.

99 Restaurants

Highlights
Great value for your money
Delicious and abundant food
Excellent service

Let me start by mentioning that the 99 Restaurants offers a great value for your money when it comes to their lobster rolls. One of the things that stood out to me was the portion size. It was a delightful surprise to see the plate filled with a generous amount of delicious lobster meat.

The roll itself was perfectly buttered and lightly toasted, providing a wonderful texture to complement the tender lobster. The meat was exceptionally fresh and had a delightful sweetness to it, which is a must-have for any lobster roll enthusiast.

What impressed me the most was not only the quality of the food but also the excellent service I received. The staff was attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about their menu items. They were more than happy to provide recommendations and answer any questions I had.

Overall, my experience at 99 Restaurants in Plymouth was nothing short of spectacular. The combination of great value for your money, delicious and abundant food, and excellent service make it a top contender for the best lobster roll in town. If you find yourself in Plymouth and craving a lobster roll, this is definitely a spot you don't want to miss.

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Cambridge.