Plymouth's Best Ice Cream [Updated 2024]

In my pursuit of the perfect scoop, I have personally tasted and reviewed 15 different ice cream shops in Plymouth. From quaint family-owned parlors to trendy gelato bars, I have searched high and low to provide you with the most accurate and delicious recommendations.

Whether you fancy classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate or crave unique and unconventional combinations, this guide has got you covered. Prepare to indulge in creamy delights that will tantalize your taste buds and awaken your love for all things frozen.

So sit back, relax, and join me on this ice cream adventure through the charming streets of Plymouth, Massachusetts.

Kilwins Chocolates, Fudge, and Ice Cream

Highlights
Beautiful candy canes
Delectable fudge
Great chocolate selection
Homemade waffle cones
Delicious ice cream

My taste buds were tantalized from the moment I stepped into Kilwins Chocolates, Fudge, and Ice Cream. The first thing that caught my eye was the display of beautiful candy canes that adorned the shop, showcasing their commitment to both artistry and quality.

But let's get down to business, the ice cream! Kilwins offers a wide range of flavors that are guaranteed to satisfy any ice cream lover's cravings. From classics like vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous options like salted caramel and mint chocolate chip, their selection is sure to please. Each scoop is lovingly crafted, delivering on both flavor and texture.

As I indulged my taste buds, I couldn't resist sampling their delectable fudge. The smooth and creamy texture melted in my mouth, leaving behind a burst of rich chocolate flavor. And the chocolate selection? Truly impressive. With everything from dark chocolate truffles to milk chocolate-covered pretzels, Kilwins is a chocolate lover's paradise.

What truly sets Kilwins apart is their attention to detail. Their homemade waffle cones are crispy perfection, providing the ideal vessel for scoops of their delicious ice cream. The staff are not only knowledgeable about their products but also passionate about creating the best ice cream experience possible.

In summary, Kilwins Chocolates, Fudge, and Ice Cream in Plymouth is a must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast. With their beautiful candy canes, delectable fudge, great chocolate selection, homemade waffle cones, and delicious ice cream, Kilwins offers an exceptional ice cream experience that will leave you craving more.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Boston.

Seaside Ice Cream

Highlights
Great selection of flavors
Unusual flavor choices
Caramel cashew
Gluten free friendly
Excellent service

Seaside Ice Cream truly stood out among the many ice cream shops I visited in Plymouth. As soon as I walked in, I was immediately drawn to their great selection of flavors. From classic choices like chocolate and vanilla to more unique options like lavender honey and avocado lime, there was something for everyone.

One flavor that caught my attention was the caramel cashew. The rich caramel combined with the crunch of the cashews created a delightful taste sensation. It was like a sweet symphony in my mouth.

What impressed me most about Seaside Ice Cream was their dedication to catering for different dietary needs. As someone who follows a gluten-free diet, I was thrilled to discover that they offered several gluten-free friendly options. This made my ice cream experience even more enjoyable, knowing that I didn't have to compromise on taste or worry about any unwanted side effects.

In addition to the exceptional ice cream, I must mention the excellent service I received at Seaside Ice Cream. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, providing recommendations and answering any questions I had.

In conclusion, Seaside Ice Cream stands out as one of the best ice cream shops in Plymouth. With their unusual flavor choices, particularly the unforgettable caramel cashew, and their commitment to being gluten-free friendly, I cannot recommend Seaside Ice Cream enough. So next time you're in Plymouth, be sure to pay a visit to Seaside Ice Cream for a truly delightful frozen treat.

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Boston.

Cold Stone Creamery

Highlights
Delicious
Great staff
Affordable
Skilled mixer

Let me start by saying, wow! Cold Stone Creamery in Plymouth is an absolute delight for ice cream lovers like me. From the first lick to the very last bite, this place offers a truly exceptional ice cream experience.

One of the highlights of Cold Stone Creamery is undoubtedly the delicious ice cream. Every flavor I sampled was bursting with flavor and had the perfect creamy texture. Whether you're a fan of classic options like Chocolate or adventurous flavors like Cake Batter, Cold Stone Creamery has something to satisfy every craving.

The staff at Cold Stone Creamery deserves a special mention for their fantastic service. They were friendly, helpful, and always willing to go the extra mile to ensure that every customer had a great experience. It's not just the ice cream that makes this place stand out, but also the great staff who make you feel welcome from the moment you walk in.

Another delightful aspect of Cold Stone Creamery is its affordability. Despite the top-notch quality of their ice cream, the prices are surprisingly reasonable. So you can indulge in their delectable treats without breaking the bank.

Last but not least, I was thoroughly impressed by the skilled mixer at Cold Stone Creamery. They take ice cream to a whole new level by customizing your order right in front of your eyes. Watching them expertly blend in mix-ins like candy, nuts, and fruit is like witnessing a work of art being created.

All in all, Cold Stone Creamery in Plymouth truly deserves its spot among the top ice cream spots in town. With its delicious flavors, great staff, and affordable prices, this is the place to indulge in a memorable ice cream experience. You simply can't miss out on this icy delight in Plymouth!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Boston.

Pebbles

Highlights
Delicious fish & chips
Tasty clam chowder
Large portion sizes
Friendly staff
Beautiful ocean view

Let me start off by saying that Pebbles is not just your average ice cream shop. It's a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Plymouth, offering an array of delectable treats that will leave your taste buds dancing with joy.

What initially caught my attention was the stunning ocean view that greeted me as I entered Pebbles. It created the perfect backdrop for indulging in some frozen delights. As I approached the counter, I was welcomed by the friendly staff, who were more than happy to assist me in exploring their extensive menu.

While my focus was on ice cream, I couldn't resist trying their renowned fish & chips and clam chowder. It was a delightful surprise to discover that Pebbles excels not only in ice cream but also in savory dishes. The fish & chips were crispy, golden, and filled with flavor, while the clam chowder was rich and creamy - a true taste of the sea.

When it finally came time for dessert, I embarked on a journey through a variety of flavors. From classic options like vanilla and chocolate, to more unique creations such as lavender honey and strawberry balsamic, Pebbles offered an assortment of delightful choices. Each scoop was generously sized and made with the finest ingredients, resulting in a heavenly treat that melted in my mouth.

Pebbles truly stands out for their commitment to quality and attention to detail. With their delicious ice cream, delightful staff, and stunning ocean view, it's no wonder they have become a beloved spot among locals and visitors alike. If you find yourself in Plymouth, make sure to indulge in the flavorsome experience that Pebbles has to offer.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Worcester.

Wicked Chill- Redbrook

Highlights
Pleasantly surprised by location
Delicious ice cream
Friendly owners
Lovely seating and atmosphere on the green
Great prices

Let me start by saying that I was pleasantly surprised by the location of Wicked Chill- Redbrook. Tucked away in Redbrook Village, this charming ice cream shop sits in the midst of a quaint green area.

As soon as I walked in, I was greeted with a warm welcome from the friendly owners. They were more than happy to guide me through their wide range of flavors and help me choose the perfect ice cream.

Speaking of flavors, the ice cream at Wicked Chill- Redbrook is absolutely delicious. From classic options like vanilla and chocolate, to unique and inventive flavors like maple bacon and lavender honey, there's something for everyone here.

Not only is the ice cream amazing, but the seating and atmosphere on the green is truly lovely. Whether you choose to enjoy your treat on one of their cozy benches or opt for a picnic blanket spread out on the grass, you'll be surrounded by the tranquil beauty of the area.

And let's not forget about the prices! Wicked Chill- Redbrook offers their delectable ice cream at great prices, allowing you to indulge without breaking the bank.

Overall, my visit to Wicked Chill- Redbrook was a delightful experience. The combination of delicious ice cream, friendly owners, and charming location makes this a must-visit spot for any ice cream lover in Plymouth.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Plymouth MI.

Frosty Friends Ice Cream & Treats

Highlights
Delicious ice cream
Hot donuts
Amazing snacks

Let me start by telling you that the ice cream at Frosty Friends is absolutely delicious. Each scoop is bursting with flavor and has the perfect creamy texture that makes every bite a delightful experience. From classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate to unique and indulgent creations like salted caramel and cookie dough, there is something for everyone's taste buds.

But the ice cream is just the beginning of the treat at Frosty Friends. One of the highlights of this place is their hot donuts. These warm, fluffy, and heavenly delights are the perfect accompaniment to your ice cream. The combination of a freshly made donut with a generous scoop of ice cream on top is simply irresistible.

In addition to their ice cream and donuts, Frosty Friends also offers a variety of amazing snacks. From freshly baked cookies to crispy waffle cones, you can find a range of delectable options to satisfy your cravings. The quality of the ingredients and the attention to detail in every dish truly sets this place apart.

The atmosphere at Frosty Friends is cozy and inviting, with friendly staff who are always ready to help you choose the perfect flavor or combination. Whether you're looking for a sweet treat on a sunny day or a comforting dessert after a long day, Frosty Friends Ice Cream & Treats is the place to be.

With its delicious ice cream, hot donuts, and amazing snacks, Frosty Friends is undeniably one of the top contenders for the title of the best ice cream in Plymouth. Don't miss out on this delightful ice cream experience!

You might also want to check out the best pasta in Boston.

Bramhall's Country Store

Highlights
Local and family-owned
Variety of food options
Delicious ice cream
Friendly service
Live lobster tank

Bramhall's Country Store is a charming, local and family-owned establishment that stole my heart with their exceptional ice cream. As I walked into the store, I was greeted by the warm and friendly staff, instantly putting me in the mood for a delightful treat.

What truly sets Bramhall's apart is the variety of food options they offer. Beyond their extensive selection of ice cream flavors, you can also indulge in mouthwatering sandwiches, wraps, and salads. It's the perfect spot to grab a quick bite before satisfying your sweet tooth.

Now, let's talk about the ice cream. Oh boy! Bramhall's delivers deliciousness with every scoop. From classic flavors like rich and creamy vanilla to unique creations like their velvety caramel ripple, each bite is an absolute delight. The quality of the ice cream is evident - smooth, flavorful, and made with love.

The friendly service provided by the staff enhances the overall experience. They are more than happy to offer recommendations, allowing you to explore new flavors and find your perfect match. You'll feel like part of the Bramhall's family by the time you leave.

One highlight that sets Bramhall's apart is their unique feature: a live lobster tank. It's a playful addition that reflects the store's commitment to providing a diverse experience for customers.

In conclusion, Bramhall's Country Store is a hidden gem in Plymouth. With their delicious ice cream, variety of food options, and friendly service, it's a must-visit for anyone seeking the best ice cream in town. Don't miss out on this delightful, local experience!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in Boston.

Friendly's

Highlights
Best burger in NE
Tasty fries
Wonderful experience
Delicious dessert
Friendly staff

My taste buds were in for a delightful treat when I stepped foot into Friendly's. Not only are they famous for their mouthwatering ice cream, but they also serve the best burger in the entire New England region! I couldn't resist trying it, and let me tell you, it lived up to the hype. Each juicy bite left me wanting more.

And let's not forget about the tasty fries. They were perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, making for the ideal companion to my burger. It was like a match made in culinary heaven.

The overall experience at Friendly's was nothing short of wonderful. The atmosphere was vibrant and welcoming, and the friendly staff made me feel right at home. They were attentive and always ready to assist with any questions or recommendations.

Now, let's talk about the real star of the show—the ice cream. Oh boy, was it delicious! It was rich, creamy, and packed with flavor. The extensive selection had my taste buds swirling with excitement. From classic vanilla to indulgent chocolate chunk, Friendly's has something for everyone.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Plymouth and in need of a sweet treat, look no further than Friendly's. With their delectable ice cream, tasty fries, and impeccable service, it's no wonder they are a top contender for the best ice cream in town. Don't miss out on this delightful experience!

You might also want to check out the best hot pot in Boston.

Cupcake Charlie's

Highlights
Delicious cupcakes
Great service
Fresh and clean
Friendly and fast
Flavorful and pretty

I have to admit, Cupcake Charlie's surprised me with their delightful ice cream creations. While the name may suggest a focus on cupcakes, their ice cream is just as mesmerizing.

As I stepped into the shop, I was greeted with a display of delicious cupcakes, tempting me with their colorful toppings and fluffy frosting. But I stayed focused on my mission - finding the best ice cream in Plymouth.

The service at Cupcake Charlie's was top-notch. The staff was welcoming, with smiles that could brighten anyone's day. They were eager to help me navigate through their impressive array of ice cream flavors, patiently offering recommendations and allowing me to sample a few favorites.

One thing that stood out to me was the cleanliness of the shop. The freshness of their ingredients was evident as I watched the staff meticulously prepare each scoop. The shop itself was fresh and clean, creating a pleasant atmosphere to enjoy my ice cream.

Not only was the service great and the shop clean, but the speed at which I received my ice cream was remarkable. The staff was friendly and fast, ensuring that I didn't wait too long for my frozen treat.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the ice cream itself. Cupcake Charlie's offers a wide variety of flavors, each flavorful and pretty. From classic favorites to unique creations, there was something for everyone. The texture was perfectly creamy, with each bite bursting with rich and indulgent flavors.

In conclusion, Cupcake Charlie's exceeded my expectations with their delicious ice cream and great service. Whether you're a cupcake lover or seeking out the best ice cream in Plymouth, this place is definitely worth a visit. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Cambridge.

sweetFrog

Highlights
Spacious and clean
Wide variety of flavors
Plenty of non-dairy options
Tons of toppings
Friendly staff

Let me start by saying that sweetFrog is a hidden gem when it comes to finding the best ice cream in Plymouth.

Walking into sweetFrog, the first thing that caught my attention was how spacious and clean the place was. It had a cheerful ambiance with colorful walls that instantly put me in a playful mood. The friendly staff, adorned in their sweetFrog t-shirts, greeted me with a warm smile.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the ice cream! With a wide variety of flavors, I was absolutely spoilt for choice. From classic flavors like creamy vanilla and rich chocolate, to unique and adventurous flavors like salted caramel popcorn and cotton candy, sweetFrog had something to satisfy every ice cream lover's craving.

What impressed me even more was the availability of plenty of non-dairy options. As someone with dietary restrictions, it was a delightful surprise to find a shop that catered to different preferences. They had a delicious assortment of non-dairy options that rivaled their dairy-based counterparts in taste and texture.

To top it all off, sweetFrog offered tons of toppings to customize your ice cream creation. From sprinkles, chocolate chips, and gummy bears, to fresh fruits and crunchy nuts, the possibilities were endless. I couldn't resist loading my ice cream with a little bit of everything!

Overall, my experience at sweetFrog in Plymouth was nothing short of delightful. The combination of a clean and welcoming atmosphere, a wide array of flavors, non-dairy options, and an abundance of toppings made it a top contender for the best ice cream in Plymouth. Whether you're a local or just passing through, sweetFrog is a must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Boston.

Ziggy's

Highlights
Best ice cream
Loved since young
Cash only
Tasty
Variety of flavors

Let me start by saying that Ziggy's is hands down, the best place to get ice cream in Plymouth. As soon as you step inside the quaint little shop, you can feel the nostalgia and love for ice cream in the air.

But what makes Ziggy's truly special is the fact that it has been a beloved destination for ice cream lovers since I was young. There's something about coming back to a place that has always been there, serving up delicious scoops of frozen joy year after year.

One thing to note is that Ziggy's only accepts cash, so make sure to have some on hand. But trust me, it's worth the extra trip to the ATM. The ice cream at Ziggy's is not only mouthwatering, but they also offer a variety of flavors that will leave you yearning for more.

The moment I took my first bite of their creamy, rich ice cream, I knew I had discovered something truly special. Each flavor was crafted with such care and precision, it was like a symphony of sweetness on my taste buds.

Whether you're a fan of classics like chocolate and vanilla or a more adventurous flavor seeker, Ziggy's has something for everyone. From their velvety smooth chocolate fudge brownie to their tangy and refreshing mango sorbet, the options are endless.

If you find yourself in Plymouth and you're in need of a sweet treat, do yourself a favor and head straight to Ziggy's. Your taste buds will thank you, and you'll understand why it's considered the reigning champion of ice cream in this charming coastal town.

Kush Kone ice cream

Highlights
Delicious flavors
Perfect portions
Great way to end the night

Let me start by saying that Kush Kone serves up some seriously delicious flavors of ice cream. From classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous options like maple bacon and lavender honey, they've got something for everyone. Each flavor was expertly crafted with a perfect blend of creaminess and sweetness, making it a delight for the tastebuds.

One thing that really stood out to me about Kush Kone was the portion sizes. It's easy to get carried away and end up with more ice cream than you can handle, but Kush Kone gets it just right. The portions are generous enough to satisfy your cravings, but not so overwhelming that you end up feeling like you've overindulged.

The atmosphere at Kush Kone is also worth mentioning. With its bright and colorful decor, it's the perfect place to indulge in a scoop or two of ice cream. Whether you're enjoying it on their cozy outdoor seating area or taking it to-go for a late-night treat, Kush Kone provides a great way to end the night on a sweet note.

Overall, I would highly recommend Kush Kone to any ice cream lover in Plymouth. With their delicious flavors, perfect portions, and great atmosphere, it's hard to go wrong. So go ahead, treat yourself and indulge in the best ice cream that Plymouth has to offer at Kush Kone. You won't be disappointed!

Gellar's Snackbar

Highlights
Delicious hot chicken sandwich
Homemade-tasting pickles
Great coleslaw
Hot and crispy onion rings
Fast and friendly service

Gellar's Snackbar in Plymouth is a hidden gem when it comes to ice cream. While most people flock to this spot for their savory treats, the ice cream offerings deserve just as much attention. As a self-proclaimed ice cream connoisseur, I was pleasantly surprised by the quality and flavors on offer.

First, let's talk about the atmosphere. Gellar's Snackbar has a charming retro vibe that immediately transports you back to a simpler time. The friendly and fast service only adds to the overall experience. As soon as I entered, I was greeted with a warm smile and guided towards their extensive ice cream menu.

Now let's dig into the ice cream itself. The flavors at Gellar's Snackbar are rich, creamy, and bursting with taste. Each spoonful was a delightful explosion of flavor. From classic vanilla to unique creations like salted caramel pretzel, there was something to satisfy every ice cream lover's craving. The homemade-tasting pickles and great coleslaw also added a delightful contrast to the sweetness of the ice cream.

One highlight at Gellar's Snackbar is their hot chicken sandwich, which perfectly complements the icy treats. The deliciously crispy and flavorful chicken, paired with their hot and crispy onion rings, creates a symphony of flavors that will leave you wanting more.

In conclusion, Gellar's Snackbar is definitely a must-visit spot for ice cream enthusiasts. With its delicious hot chicken sandwich, homemade-tasting pickles, great coleslaw, and fast and friendly service, you can't go wrong. So next time you find yourself in Plymouth, be sure to stop by Gellar's for a delightful ice cream experience that will leave you wanting seconds.

Fedele's Chocolates

Highlights
Good selection of chocolates
Delicious turtles and truffles
Friendly service
Great tasting sugar free chocolate
Many options to choose from

Let me just say, this place is a chocolate lover's dream! As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by a display of mouthwatering chocolates that made me weak in the knees. The variety and selection at Fedele's Chocolates is truly impressive.

One of the highlights of this place is the wide array of chocolates they offer. From delectable turtles to rich truffles, they have something to cater to every chocolate aficionado out there. Every bite is like a little piece of heaven melting in your mouth.

The service at Fedele's Chocolates is top-notch. The staff are friendly, knowledgeable, and always eager to help you find your perfect chocolate match. Whether you're a seasoned chocolate connoisseur or a newbie looking to explore, they will guide you in the right direction. Plus, they offer the option of sugar-free chocolate, which is just as delicious as the regular options.

With so many options to choose from, you can easily satisfy your sweet tooth and find your new favorite treat at Fedele's Chocolates. Whether you prefer milk chocolate, dark chocolate, or something in between, they have it all. The quality and taste of their chocolates are unparalleled.

So, if you're in Plymouth and looking for the best ice cream in town, don't forget to stop by Fedele's Chocolates. Trust me, you won't be disappointed. Your taste buds will thank you!

Yogies Cafe

Highlights
Fantastic lobster roll
Delicious ice cream
Great service
Quick ice cream service

Yogies Cafe truly exceeded my expectations during my quest to find the best ice cream in Plymouth. From the moment I stepped inside, I was met with a warm and inviting atmosphere, ready to indulge in the delightful treat that awaited me.

Not only does Yogies Cafe boast a fantastic selection of ice cream flavors, but they also have an assortment of toppings and mix-ins to take your ice cream experience to the next level. From gooey hot fudge to crunchy cookie crumbles, they have it all.

One highlight at Yogies Cafe is their fantastic lobster roll. It may sound odd to mention in an ice cream review, but trust me, it is worth mentioning. The lobster roll is a mouthwatering revelation, filled with fresh lobster meat and perfectly seasoned to bring out the flavors. It’s a savory experience that perfectly complements the sweet indulgence of their ice cream offerings.

The ice cream itself is absolutely delicious. With each creamy spoonful, you can taste the quality and care put into creating these frozen delights. The flavors are rich and bold, leaving you wanting more with each bite.

What truly sets Yogies Cafe apart is their exceptional service. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and always ready to help you select the perfect flavor combination. And to top it off, the service is quick, ensuring you don't have to wait long to satisfy your ice cream cravings.

If you're on the hunt for the best ice cream in Plymouth, look no further than Yogies Cafe. With its fantastic lobster roll, delicious ice cream, great service, and quick service, it's an experience that you don't want to miss.