Plymouth's Best Cake [Updated 2025]

I have personally sampled and reviewed 15 different cake options in this charming coastal town, and I am excited to share my findings with you. Whether you have a sweet tooth or simply appreciate a delicious slice of cake, you'll find something to suit your taste in Plymouth.

From traditional flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique creations that push the boundaries of cake-making, this guide offers a comprehensive review of the top confectioneries in the area. So grab a fork and indulge in the mouthwatering world of Plymouth's best cake options.

Get ready to satisfy your dessert cravings like never before!

Two Buoys Cakes

Highlights
Superb skills
Creative crafting
Heavenly carrot cake
Beautiful surprise cake
Delicious chocolate with raspberry

Let me tell you, Two Buoys Cakes has some of the most superb skills when it comes to cake crafting. From the moment I walked in, I was captivated by the heavenly aroma filling the air. The display case was a work of art, showcasing a beautiful array of cakes, each one more creatively crafted than the last.

One cake that left a lasting impression on me was their carrot cake. Oh my, it was a slice of pure perfection! Moist and flavorful, with just the right amount of spice and a cream cheese frosting that was simply divine. It was truly a slice of cake heaven.

Another standout was a surprise cake I had the pleasure of trying. The exterior was beautifully decorated, but it was the moment of cutting into it that truly took my breath away. Layers upon layers of colorful sponge cake, adorned with sprinkles and filled with a luscious vanilla cream. Each bite was a delightful surprise, bursting with flavor and joy.

If you're a chocolate lover like me, you cannot miss their chocolate cake with raspberry. It was an absolute delight for the taste buds. Rich, decadent chocolate paired perfectly with the tartness of the raspberry filling. It was a match made in cake heaven.

In conclusion, Two Buoys Cakes in Plymouth is a true gem. Their superb skills and creative crafting make for an unforgettable cake experience. Whether you're in the mood for a heavenly carrot cake, a beautiful surprise cake, or a delicious chocolate with raspberry, you won't be disappointed. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best lobster roll in Boston.

Sweet Sense Gluten Free baked goods

Highlights
Safe and delicious gluten free cake
Great for weddings and special events
Surprised non-celiac guests with gluten free cake
Affordable prices for custom cakes
Inclusive options for individuals with celiac disease

Let me start by saying that as a gluten-free cake lover, finding a bakery that not only offers safe and delicious options but also exceeds expectations is like finding a pot of gold at the end of a rainbow. Sweet Sense Gluten Free baked goods in Plymouth is that pot of gold!

If you're looking for the perfect cake for your wedding or a special event, Sweet Sense Gluten Free baked goods has got you covered. Their cakes are not only gluten-free but also visually stunning, making them a beautiful centerpiece for any occasion.

As I indulged in a slice of their gluten-free cake, I was blown away by the taste and texture. It's hard to believe that it's gluten-free! The flavors were rich, the cake moist, and the frosting was perfectly balanced. I even served it to some non-celiac guests without telling them it was gluten-free, and they couldn't believe it.

One of the highlights of Sweet Sense is their affordable prices for custom cakes. Not only do you get a safe and delicious gluten-free cake, but you also get it at a reasonable price. It's a win-win situation!

What truly sets Sweet Sense Gluten Free baked goods apart is their commitment to inclusivity. With options specifically designed for individuals with celiac disease, they ensure that everyone can enjoy a slice of cake without any worries.

In conclusion, Sweet Sense Gluten Free baked goods in Plymouth is a gem for those seeking the best gluten-free cakes in the area. Their attention to detail, affordability, and dedication to inclusivity make them a top choice for any occasion. So why settle for anything less? Let Sweet Sense Gluten Free baked goods sprinkle some joy into your life!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Boston.

Hearth Artisan Bread

Highlights
Great pastries
Amazing breakfast sandwiches
Delicious pizza
Outdoor sitting area
Best iced coffee

Let me start by saying that Hearth Artisan Bread truly knows how to satisfy a sweet tooth. While this review may be focused on cakes, I must mention their other delightful offerings. Firstly, their selection of pastries is simply outstanding. Each one is a work of art, and it's clear that the bakers at Hearth have honed their craft to perfection.

But let's get to the real star of the show - the cakes. The moment you step into Hearth, you're greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly baked goodies. They have a wide variety of cake options, and trust me, it was a tough decision to make.

After much contemplation, I decided to try their signature chocolate cake. And oh boy, was that a wise choice! The cake was incredibly moist, with a rich and decadent chocolate flavor. It was beautifully decorated with a smooth and glossy ganache, making it almost too pretty to eat. Almost.

One thing that truly sets Hearth Artisan Bread apart is the attention to detail. From the precise piping on their cakes to the whimsical decorations that adorn their charming cafe, it's evident that they take pride in their craft.

Whether you're in the mood for a slice of cake or craving a hearty breakfast sandwich, Hearth Artisan Bread has got you covered. Don't forget to grab a cup of their best-in-town iced coffee and enjoy it in their lovely outdoor sitting area. Trust me, it's the perfect way to start your day.

In conclusion, I can confidently say that Hearth Artisan Bread is a must-visit for cake lovers in Plymouth. Their dedication to creating delicious and visually stunning treats is commendable. Stop by and treat yourself to some of the best cakes in town. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Boston.

Cape Batter Bakeshop & Cakery

Highlights
Beautiful wrapping
Timely delivery
Delicious desserts
Professional service
Variety of flavors

Let me start by saying, the packaging of the cakes at Cape Batter Bakeshop & Cakery is simply beautiful. Each cake is elegantly wrapped, making it feel like a special gift just for you. And speaking of gifts, the timely delivery service provided by the bakery was exceptional. My cake arrived on time and in perfect condition, ready to be devoured.

Now, let's talk about the most important aspect - the taste. Oh boy, the desserts at Cape Batter Bakeshop & Cakery are a delight! Each slice is a heavenly creation that will make your taste buds dance with joy. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique combinations like lavender and lemon, they truly offer a variety of flavors to satisfy any craving.

Besides the tasty treats, I was impressed by the professional service I received. The staff was knowledgeable, helpful, and passionate about what they do. Their expertise in creating mouthwatering cakes was evident.

In conclusion, if you're looking for the best cake experience in Plymouth, I wholeheartedly recommend Cape Batter Bakeshop & Cakery. With their beautiful packaging, timely delivery, delicious desserts, professional service, and variety of flavors, they have all the ingredients to make your cake dreams come true. So, why wait? Treat yourself to a slice of bliss today!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Worcester.

Cole's Cake Push Pops

Cole's Cake Push Pops in Plymouth takes cake to a whole new level with their delightful and innovative creations. These whimsical treats are not just delicious, but they also bring out the inner child in you. Each push pop is a burst of flavors that will leave you wanting more. The layers of moist cake, creamy frosting, and tempting fillings are a match made in dessert heaven. From classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate to unique combinations like strawberry lemonade, Cole's offers a wide range of options to satisfy every sweet tooth. If you're looking for a fun and scrumptious cake experience, Cole's Cake Push Pops is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Plymouth MI.

Crumbl - Plymouth

Highlights
Thick and delicate cookies
Perfect level of sweetness
Worth every penny
Variety of delicious flavors
Great place to try different cookies

Crumbl - Plymouth is a delightful bakery that specializes in creating thick and delicate cookies that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. As a self-proclaimed cake connoisseur, I was skeptical at first. But boy, was I in for a treat!

The moment I walked through the door, I was greeted with the heavenly aroma of freshly baked cookies. The place was bustling with happy customers who couldn't help but smile at the sight of the vibrant display of cookies. Each one looked like a work of art, perfectly baked with a golden exterior and a gooey center.

I decided to try their infamous chocolate chip cookie, and it was nothing short of perfection. The cookie had just the right level of sweetness, with melt-in-your-mouth chocolate chips that added a burst of flavor. It was large enough to satisfy my craving, worth every penny.

What sets Crumbl - Plymouth apart from other bakeries is their ever-changing menu of cookie flavors. From classic favorites like snickerdoodle and sugar cookie to unique creations like raspberry cheesecake and cinnamon toast, there is something for everyone. It's a great place to indulge in your sweet tooth and try different cookies each time you visit.

In conclusion, if you're looking for the best cake in Plymouth, look no further than Crumbl - Plymouth. With their thick and delicate cookies, perfect level of sweetness, and a variety of delicious flavors, it's a bakery that should not be missed. So go ahead, treat yourself, and savor the delightful experience at Crumbl - Plymouth.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in Boston.

Piece of Cake

Highlights
Beautiful wedding cake
Variety of cake flavors
Accommodating dietary restrictions
Delicious gluten-free and vegan cupcakes

Piece of Cake in Plymouth is a hidden gem when it comes to finding the best cakes in town. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly baked goodies. The first thing that caught my eye was a beautifully decorated wedding cake on display. It was a true masterpiece, with intricate details and elegant design. This certainly set high expectations for the rest of their offerings.

And let me tell you, Piece of Cake did not disappoint. They have an impressive variety of cake flavors that will satisfy any craving. From classics like chocolate and vanilla to unique options like red velvet and salted caramel, there's something for everyone's taste buds. Each slice I tried was moist, flavorful, and left me wanting more.

What truly impressed me about Piece of Cake was their commitment to accommodating dietary restrictions. As a person who follows a gluten-free diet, I was thrilled to discover their selection of gluten-free cupcakes. These little treats were divine, you would never guess they were gluten-free. They were moist, fluffy, and packed with flavor.

Not only that, but Piece of Cake goes the extra mile by offering vegan options as well. Their vegan cupcakes were a pleasant surprise. It's not easy to find vegan desserts that taste as good as their traditional counterparts, but Piece of Cake nailed it. The rich and creamy frosting paired perfectly with the fluffy cupcakes, creating a truly delightful experience.

Overall, my visit to Piece of Cake was a true delight. From the beautiful wedding cake to the variety of flavors and accommodating dietary options, this bakery knows how to make cake lovers happy. If you find yourself in Plymouth and in need of a cake fix, make sure to pay Piece of Cake a visit. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best dumplings in Boston.

Cupcake Charlie's

Highlights
Delicious
Great Service
Fresh and Clean
Flavorful and Pretty

Let me start by saying, "Wow!" Cupcake Charlie's truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best cake destinations in Plymouth. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and an inviting aroma of freshly baked goodies.

The selection of cupcakes at Cupcake Charlie's is nothing short of extraordinary. Each bite was a symphony of flavors that danced on my tongue. The cakes were moist, light, and just the right amount of sweetness. The delicious buttercream frosting was a perfect complement, adding an extra layer of decadence to every bite.

Not only were the cupcakes incredibly tasty, but the service at Cupcake Charlie's was exceptional. The staff members were friendly, knowledgeable, and passionate about their craft. They were more than happy to offer recommendations and answer any questions I had. Their attention to detail and commitment to providing great service truly took my experience to the next level.

Beyond the enchanting flavors and excellent service, Cupcake Charlie's also stood out for its impeccable cleanliness. The bakery was spotless, and every cupcake displayed was a work of art. Each cupcake was flavorful and pretty, making it almost too beautiful to eat.

If you find yourself in Plymouth and have a craving for cake, look no further than Cupcake Charlie's. Their fresh and clean establishment, combined with their heavenly treats and top-notch service, place them firmly at the top of the cake food chain in Plymouth. Don't miss the chance to indulge your taste buds at this delightful bakery.

You might also want to check out the best hot pot in Boston.

Cafe Create a Cake LLC

Highlights
Terrific and beautiful
Exceeded expectations
Easy to deal with
All cakes knocked out
Strongly recommend

Let me start by saying that this place is terrific. From the moment I stepped in, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the sweet aroma of freshly baked cakes filled the air. It was like stepping into a cake wonderland.

Not only were the cakes beautiful to look at, but they also exceeded my expectations in terms of taste. Each bite was a divine explosion of flavors that danced on my tongue. It was evident that the bakers at Cafe Create a Cake LLC put their heart and soul into their creations.

What I appreciated the most about my experience at Cafe Create a Cake LLC was how easy they were to deal with. The staff was friendly and accommodating, and they took the time to understand my preferences and needs. Moreover, they were open to customizing cakes to suit special occasions, which was a huge plus for me.

Out of all the cakes I've tasted in Plymouth, Cafe Create a Cake LLC knocked them out of the park. It is without a doubt a strong contender for the title of the best cake in town. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, a wedding, or simply indulging in some sweet delight, I strongly recommend giving Cafe Create a Cake LLC a try.

So, dear readers, if you find yourselves in Plymouth craving a piece of heaven on a plate, head over to Cafe Create a Cake LLC and let their creations work their magic on your taste buds. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Cambridge.

Walmart Bakery

Let me tell you, I was pleasantly surprised by the cake options at Walmart Bakery in Plymouth. The variety they offer is simply impressive. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to fancier options like red velvet and caramel, they've got something to satisfy every cake lover's craving. The moistness and freshness of their cakes were on point, making each bite a delightful experience. The fluffy frosting was a perfect complement to the cake, adding a burst of sweetness to every mouthful. While Walmart Bakery may not be the most boutique option in town, their cakes definitely deserve a spot in the best cake in Plymouth conversation.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Boston.

KETO 1620 Bakery Gluten-Free

Highlights
Incredible keto bakery
Outstanding customer service
Free items provided
High quality baked goods
Delicious and healthy options

Let me start by saying that the KETO 1620 Bakery Gluten-Free is an incredible keto-friendly bakery that left me absolutely impressed.

From the moment I walked in, it was evident that they prioritize their customers' satisfaction. The outstanding customer service made me feel welcomed and valued. The staff was knowledgeable and eager to assist, making the overall experience all the more enjoyable.

To my delight, the bakery offered a selection of free items for customers to try. This gesture further emphasized their commitment to providing the best possible experience. It's admirable when a business goes above and beyond to please their customers.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the baked goods. The high quality of their cakes truly stood out. Each bite was a burst of flavors and textures that satisfied my sweet tooth while still adhering to the bakery's gluten-free and keto principles.

What sets KETO 1620 Bakery Gluten-Free apart is not only their delicious creations, but also the fact that they offer healthy options. It was refreshing to indulge guilt-free, knowing that their cakes were made with wholesome ingredients.

In conclusion, KETO 1620 Bakery Gluten-Free is a must-visit spot for cake enthusiasts in Plymouth. Their incredible keto bakery with outstanding customer service and an array of delicious and healthy options truly sets them apart. Keep an eye out for this gem when searching for the best cake in Plymouth!

You might also want to check out the best steak house in Boston.

Yellow Deli To Go Shop & Bakery

Highlights
Friendly service
Great food
Beautiful atmosphere
Variety of food and drinks

As I ventured into the Yellow Deli To Go Shop & Bakery, I was immediately greeted by a warm and friendly smile from the staff. Their customer service was impeccable, making me feel right at home from the moment I stepped through the door.

The bakery not only offers a wide array of delicious cakes but also a range of mouthwatering food options. From delectable sandwiches to savory soups, there is certainly something to satisfy every palate. The menu boasts a variety of choices that will leave you spoilt for choice.

The atmosphere within the bakery is simply beautiful. The charming decor, with its rustic accents and cozy seating areas, creates an inviting ambiance. It's a place where you can truly relax and enjoy your dessert.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the cakes. The Yellow Deli To Go Shop & Bakery offers an impressive selection of cakes that are sure to impress even the most discerning cake connoisseur. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique creations such as lavender and lemon, each slice is a true work of art.

Whether you're looking for a sweet treat to brighten your day or a whole cake to celebrate a special occasion, Yellow Deli To Go Shop & Bakery is definitely a must-visit spot in Plymouth. With their friendly service, great food, beautiful atmosphere, and variety of options, it's no wonder why this bakery has become a favorite among cake enthusiasts in the area.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in Boston Chinatown.

Country Kitchen-Lepage Bkrs

Country Kitchen-Lepage Bkrs in Plymouth is a hidden gem that truly nails the art of cake-making. As soon as I walked in, the smell of freshly baked goodies filled the air, making my mouth water in anticipation. The cakes on display were a sight to behold, with their meticulous designs and vibrant colors. And oh, the taste! Each bite was a burst of flavor, with layers so moist and frosting so decadent that it felt like a happy dance in my mouth. The staff was friendly and accommodating, which added to the overall delightful experience. Country Kitchen-Lepage Bkrs is definitely a top contender for the best cake in Plymouth.

You might also want to check out the best desserts in Boston.

Panera Bread

Highlights
Welcoming atmosphere
Comfy leather chairs
Great for getting work done
Consistently delicious food
Crave-worthy menu options

Panera Bread in Plymouth is a place that not only satisfies your cravings but also provides a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly baked goods, instantly putting a smile on my face.

I found myself drawn to the comfy leather chairs, perfect for settling down and enjoying a slice of cake while catching up on work or indulging in a good book. The ambience was just right, with a mix of natural light and soft music playing in the background.

Now, let's talk about the highlight of the visit — the cakes! Panera Bread consistently delivers delicious treats that keep me coming back for more. From their classic carrot cake to the decadent chocolate fudge cake, each slice is a delightful experience. The cakes are moist, perfectly balanced in sweetness, and always leave me wanting another bite.

What sets Panera Bread apart from other cake spots in Plymouth is their crave-worthy menu options. Whether you're looking for a comforting slice of cake to lift your spirits or a sweet treat to celebrate a special occasion, they have got you covered.

In conclusion, Panera Bread in Plymouth is a haven for cake lovers. So, if you find yourself craving a slice of heavenly goodness, don't hesitate to visit this delightful bakery. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best fish and chips in Boston.

Marshland Restaurants & Bakeries

Highlights
Hidden gem
Amazing service
Delicious food
Generous portions
Homey atmosphere

Let me begin by saying that Marshland Restaurants & Bakeries is truly a hidden gem when it comes to cake in Plymouth. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with amazing service and a warm, inviting atmosphere.

But let's get to the important part - the cake! Marshland definitely knows how to deliver in that department. I had the pleasure of trying their signature chocolate cake, and let me tell you, it was a slice of heaven. The cake was moist and rich, with a decadent chocolate flavor that lingered on my taste buds. It was adorned with a generous layer of velvety smooth chocolate frosting, creating the perfect balance of sweetness.

What impressed me the most was the generous portions. Marshland doesn't hold back. Each slice was satisfyingly large and worth every calorie. I couldn't resist going back for seconds!

Not only does Marshland excel in cake creation, but their delicious food and overall menu selection is also worth noting. The bakers and chefs here are true culinary artists.

If you're searching for the best cake in Plymouth, look no further than Marshland Restaurants & Bakeries. The combination of their homey atmosphere, incredible service, and mouthwatering cakes will have you coming back for more. Don't just take my word for it, give them a visit and let your taste buds thank you.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in Boston.